yunohost app map do not list mumble app if installed

[yunohost-bot]

Original Redmine Issue: 927

Author Name: moul

---

None

[Psycojoker]

@M5oul that looks suuuuper weird, are you sure the app was installed correctly?

[Jibec]

I do confirm the issue

ff.jb9.fr/: Funkwhale
jb9.fr/baikal: Baikal
jb9.fr/date: OpenSondage
jb9.fr/ffsync: Firefox Sync Server
jb9.fr/kanboard/: Redirect
jb9.fr/kresus: Kresus
p.jb9.fr/: PeerTube
w.jb9.fr/pixelfed: Pixelfed

jb@jb9:~$ sudo yunohost app list --installed
apps: 
  0: 
    description: Serveur CalDAV+CardDAV léger
    id: baikal
    installed: True
    label: Baikal
    license: GPL-3.0
    name: Baikal
  1: 
    description: Le serveur de synchronisation de Mozilla, pour héberger vos données Firefox
    id: ffsync
    installed: True
    label: Firefox Sync Server
    license: MPL-2.0
    name: Firefox Sync Server
  2: 
    description: A modern, convivial and free music server
    id: funkwhale
    installed: True
    label: Funkwhale
    license: BSD-3-Clause
    name: Funkwhale
  3: 
    description: Kresus est un outil personnel de gestion de finances.
    id: kresus
    installed: True
    label: Kresus
    license: AGPL-3.0-only
    name: Kresus
  4: 
    description: Mumble est un logiciel libre de voix sur IP (VoIP), son principal usage étant la communication pendant les parties de jeux en réseau.
    id: mumbleserver
    installed: True
    label: Mumble Server
    license: BSD-3-Clause
    name: Mumble Server
  5: 
    description: Mumble est un logiciel libre de voix sur IP (VoIP), son principal usage étant la communication pendant les parties de jeux en réseau.
    id: mumbleserver__2
    installed: True
    label: Mumble Server
    license: BSD-3-Clause
    name: Mumble Server
  6: 
    description: OpenSondage sert à faire des sondages sans authentification pour trouver une date de réunion qui convienne à toutes les personnes concernées.
    id: opensondage
    installed: True
    label: OpenSondage
    license: CECILL-B
    name: OpenSondage
  7: 
    description: Video streaming platform using P2P directly in the web browser, connected to a federated network
    id: peertube
    installed: True
    label: PeerTube
    license: AGPL-3.0-only
    name: PeerTube
  8: 
    description: Federated Image Sharing
    id: pixelfed
    installed: True
    label: Pixelfed
    license: MIT
    name: Pixelfed
  9: 
    description: Créer une redirection ou un proxy vers un autre emplacement
    id: redirect
    installed: True
    label: Redirect
    license: AGPL-3.0-or-later
    name: Redirect

I think it's because there is no call to ynh_webpath_register

Registering URL add a domain value: https://github.com/YunoHost/yunohost/blob/stretch-unstable/src/yunohost/app.py#L1138 While listing application through map is filtering: https://github.com/YunoHost/yunohost/blob/stretch-unstable/src/yunohost/app.py#L401

[Psycojoker]

It's because mumble doesn't have a domain settings entry no?

[Jibec]

the issue was the same even before this commit: https://github.com/YunoHost-Apps/mumbleserver_ynh/commit/1e6a9211536dfe410b802ccd599fd4e8eb4b6c3f

so, if I understand the question, this means there is no connection with having a setting named domain.

[Psycojoker]

An application will only appear in app_map if it has a domain (logic), if I remember correctly, before, mumble application didn't have a "domain" settings so it couldn't appear.

And if it has a domain_$something it won't appears neither.

Which is logic and the expected behavior: this app is not mapped on any domain/path.

The domain settings has been added after this ticket https://github.com/YunoHost-Apps/mumbleserver_ynh/commit/691b1abb774c7b927db4aced766d2e3099a2313a and today it's not used any more (in favor of "domain_mumble" instead) so it's expected that this app doesn't appear in "app_map" because ... it's can't be mapped.

[Jibec]

oh, you're right, if domain value exist in the application, it does appear:

jb@jb9:~$ sudo yunohost app setting mumbleserver domain --value="jb9.fr"
jb@jb9:~$ sudo yunohost app map
ff.jb9.fr/: Kresus
jb9.fr/: Mumble Server
jb9.fr/baikal: Baikal
jb9.fr/date: OpenSondage
jb9.fr/ffsync: Firefox Sync Server
jb9.fr/kanboard/: Redirect
jb9.fr/merde: Weblate
jb9.fr/webi: Weblate
jb9.fr/weblate: Weblate
p.jb9.fr/: PeerTube

then I assume we can close this issue as mumble's domain value was removed because of this core issue: https://github.com/YunoHost/yunohost/pull/512

or we can consider YunoHost should list apps not related to a domain. I have no opinion on this.

[Psycojoker]

or we can consider YunoHost should list apps not related to a domain. I have no opinion on this.

It can't :/ This function is a "mapping" between domain/path → application, if there is not domain it's impossible to do this mapping :/

I'm closing this issue following the conclusion of this discussion, feel free to reopen.