Peer review - Githubissues

Yuxin-Sun-Caroline / Active_Homeless_Imbalance_Toronto

This is a repo containing all data files, R code and other files

0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer review #1

Open heyuchengzhang opened 1 month ago

heyuchengzhang commented 1 month ago

Opening statement summary

An interesting paper about "Active Homeless Population: A Growing Imbalance in Proportions".

Strong positive points

It was good that you got this working.

Critical improvements needed

R was not cited
Add Author, date, and repo
Add Abstract
Add Introduction
Add data
Add Measurement
Add Discussion
Add Cross-references, Graphs/tables and Referencing
Add some meaningful commits
Add Sketches and more scripts
Cheek the Reproducibility to make it meet requirements

Suggestions for improvement:

Update README
Add more comments to the scripts

Evaluation:

A good start. Keep working!

Estimated mark:

21 of 65. (According to the Rubric)

Reason:

Good start, but need to add something more.

Yuxin-Sun-Caroline commented 1 month ago

Sorry, I don't know the file is loaded to you properly. I had my R cited, the title and author are all added, my data and intro and graphs and measurement are all showed on the paper. I do agree I need more scripts and sketches for this. Thank you for telling me this ;)