ZeroK-RTS / Zero-K

Open source RTS game running on the Spring/Recoil engine
https://zero-k.info
GNU General Public License v2.0
686 stars 205 forks source link

Unit Rename Brainstorming #2379

Closed CrazyEddieTK closed 6 years ago

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

@GoogleFrog wants to finish renaming units to get rid of the remaining OTA names. The goal is to make Zero-K feel like a new game that's a "spiritual successor" to TA (like SupCom, PA, and Ashes) rather than simply a mod of TA. This will be important for the Steam release and concomitant publicity push.

I, GF, @Aquanim, and others have been brainstorming about the renames here: http://etherpad.springrts.com/p/renames

I'm opening a ticket to get greater visibility and encourage participation from the developers and other interested parties (especially @dvr333, who has to say these names out loud more than anyone else). Comments and suggestions are welcome either here or on the etherpad.

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

@GoogleFrog - I think I am done for now, pending further feedback. All the units are covered, I've incorporated everyone's feedback or pushed back with justifications where I thought it appropriate, and where there are multiple viable candidates I've listed my favorites.

I think at this point you need to provide additional feedback, solicit additional input from others, or make some decisions.

If you'd like I can compile all the changes into a single coherent list for easy review, but I'm holding off on that until you give us your opinions on what we have so far.

GoogleFrog commented 7 years ago

Thanks, I'll take a look.

GoogleFrog commented 7 years ago

Are you going to have a look?

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

Been tied up, will review and add further remarks later today.

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

Provided responses to about two-thirds of the recent comments. More later.

As I've responded, I've moved the comments out of the compiled unit list and into a separate comments section, and marked which units still need further discussion and/or decisions made.

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

Responded to all recent comments, updated status of all units on the master list.

I think you should actively solicit additional input from others, both to provide more feedback on the current proposals and to generate more ideas for names where we still need them.

I encourage anyone reading this ticket to take a look at http://etherpad.springrts.com/p/renames and to offer comments where you think they'd be helpful. Skip to the section about two-thirds of the way down labeled "Provisional Full Renamed List of Units and Factories"; everything above that is early brainstorming and is now effectively superseded.

Anarchid commented 7 years ago

I think if you are renaming Light Vehicle Factory to Rover Assembly, the it also may make sense to update unit descriptions to use the term "Rover" instead of "Vehicle".

GoogleFrog commented 7 years ago

No updates?

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

Not much has changed since my last comment above. There's been a small bit of discussion on a few points, and you've suggested Sylph for Rocko, Machete for Cobra, and pushed back on Caltrop and Harriers.

I think I've provided all of the input that I have to provide at this time; anything else I'd say would just be repeating myself.

You need more opinions, more ideas, or more decisions.

GoogleFrog commented 7 years ago

I've got the last comment on a lot of it.

CrazyEddieTK commented 7 years ago

Added feedback based on your tentative choices.

I wish we could get input from more people than just you, me, Aquanim, and whoever is writing in green.

GoogleFrog commented 7 years ago

I think @sprunk is in green. I wish people would enter their names using the top right colour selector.

GoogleFrog commented 6 years ago

Done. Application is mostly done too.