ZeyiCai / Stillbirth-Licenses-Statistcs

0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer review1 #1

Open Yuechen-Zhang603 opened 1 month ago

Yuechen-Zhang603 commented 1 month ago

Pros: I think this is a near-perfect paper in every way, it has everything a paper should contain, an abstract, an introduction, a summary of the data, etc., and it also has a table of contents on the title page with the order of contents and page numbers. This allows the reader to be well organized and quickly get a general impression of the paper. Another thing that I think is kind of a highlight is that not only are there three charts in the text, but the original data is listed before the specific charts are analysed, making the source of the data more clear. A detailed textual analysis outlines the Civic Centre's data records and targeted solutions, assistance and care for this public health problem. Three graphical sub-tables document trends through distribution, regional factors, and time.

Cons:

  1. Introduction can be broken down into multiple paragraphs Although the INTO section is perfectly fine when it comes to content, I feel that it could have had more detail and could have been broken up into multiple paragraphs. 2-3 paragraphs would have looked more concise and made the readers more eager to read.
  2. Lack for the reference part I didn't see any references in the text other than the usual cireR and opendatatoronto. Just as a heads up, you should include a couple of references and add them to the reference page and reference.bib files on the last page of the text.
  3. README file update I only saw the README file title is updated with your paper, however, I don't think you have do the change for the rest of content, such as the LLM usage part. So if not, please do the change in the final draft.