Peer Review #3

[kevicai]

Opening Statement Summary This paper investigates the causes of TTC delays in Toronto. The paper finds that TTC is more prone to delays during peak hours.

Strong Positive Points The paper explores the dataset with a variety of figures, providing insights to help understand how the variables in the dataset look like.

Critical Improvements Needed

• Reference R and R libraries used
• Explain what each variable in the dataset represents
• Explain why or why not you didn't use similar datasets
• Provide details on how the data is measured

Suggestions for Improvement

• Maybe narrow down your topic and ask a question that is easy to answer with your figures.
• Data section is worth the most marks, be sure to focus on it the most

Evaluation

• -1 R not cited (auto 0)
• -1 No LLM usage
• -1 Title is a bit board and doesn't tell what happens at the end of paper
• -4 No abstract
• -3 For Data, as no explanation on similar dataset and variables in dataset
• -4 Measurement not explained
• -3 Not enough references
• -2 No sketches

Estimated Mark: 45/64

Reason for Evaluation: Please see above

[aakash2002]

Thanks for the review. I've updated the repo to reflect this!