aamishi / TorontoniansCombatClimateChange

0 stars 0 forks source link

from XuanangRen Peer review for aamishi #4

Open JanosRenAI opened 1 month ago

JanosRenAI commented 1 month ago

Overall, your paper appears to be incomplete at this stage.

Strong Positive Points: You have renamed the Rproj file, making your work more identifiable. The LLM section has been updated, which indicates progress toward completing the paper. Critical Improvements Needed: It is important to update the paper with more content as soon as possible to receive more valuable feedback from peers. Suggestions for Improvement: Aside from renaming the Rproj file and updating the title, the majority of the paper seems unfinished. More sections need to be completed for a thorough review. Please consider the following: Update your datasets. Expand your literature review. Provide additional LLM details, sketches, and conclusions in the paper. Remove the redundant README.html file since you already have a README.md file. Evaluation: By incorporating better examples and detailed dataset analysis, the overall quality and score of the paper will likely improve. Focus on completing and refining the content. Estimated Mark: 50 out of 100. Reason: The paper is not complete and requires significant updates.