aap / skygfx

Bringing the PS2 graphics of GTA San Andreas to PC
219 stars 18 forks source link

Car parts are turning all green when falling off #36

Open MOnkeMan5009 opened 2 weeks ago

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

in short, tearing down the bumper or hood of a car makes it turn green instead of whats it supposed to

PC Skygfx : Grand Theft Auto  San Andreas Screenshot 2024 11 08 - 14 28 22 17

PS2 Skygfx : Grand Theft Auto  San Andreas Screenshot 2024 11 08 - 14 28 19 09

Grand Theft Auto  San Andreas Screenshot 2024 11 08 - 14 20 27 27

another example of ps2 :

and here is PC with no problem : Grand Theft Auto  San Andreas Screenshot 2024 11 08 - 14 27 44 13

I have latest silentpatch and skygfx

Lethality5001 commented 2 weeks ago

@aap

aap commented 2 weeks ago

This was not a problem in the past, but perhaps it's related to the new version of silentpatch?

Lethality5001 commented 2 weeks ago

This was not a problem in the past, but perhaps it's related to the new version of silentpatch?

i remember that this was not a problem in the past, im not sure if its a silentpatch problem, because Pc skygfx is fine. i even tried a skygfx asi from 2022 as a test and same thing . i have no idea. Can that silentpatch guy see this too? I aint the only one with this

aap commented 2 weeks ago

yes, we have talked about it on discord and he's investigating it. so far it's difficult because he cannot reproduce it.

Lethality5001 commented 2 weeks ago

yes, we have talked about it on discord and he's investigating it. so far it's difficult because he cannot reproduce it.

there seems to be other posts related to this on reddit too. some people said its skygfx fault

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

yes, we have talked about it on discord and he's investigating it. so far it's difficult because he cannot reproduce it.

Can you send some older silentpatch file to test if thats the case? many say its skygfx yeah. Also, maybe give me ur personal discord? could test further. im pretty good at spotting imperfections lol

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

FOUND The problem. its silentpatch. took an older version of it. no problems. Look here recording, even switching GFX at the end for you to see :

https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/55237e17-a43c-4bd8-970e-c512a7e9b98a

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

FOUND The problem. its silentpatch. took an older version of it. no problems. Look here recording, even switching GFX at the end for you to see :

8mb.video-zuY-HlL7IYGj.mp4

Could you share your exact config file? I am using skygfx myself but never encountered this

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

i can't damn post the entire file here, so i guess zip with link it is : https://www.mediafire.com/file/d5xcq82m04qisfa/skygfx_configs.zip/file (Also, im using skygfx 4.2 extended a or whatever it was called, apparently b got rid of some rain reflections as one guy said in another issue ticket ) But the configs didnt seem to matter much, PC worked with your latest silentpatch but the rest didn't. using an older silentpatch from like 2020 and now it works fine

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

(Also, im using skygfx 4.2 extended a or whatever it was called, apparently b got rid of some rain reflections as one guy said in another issue ticket )

With aap's SkyGfx, I cannot reproduce this issue on any of your configs.

image

It might be something Extended introduced, but I can't know what.

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

(Also, im using skygfx 4.2 extended a or whatever it was called, apparently b got rid of some rain reflections as one guy said in another issue ticket )

With aap's SkyGfx, I cannot reproduce this issue on any of your configs.

image

It might be something Extended introduced, but I can't know what.

perhaps... i seen you comment on some reddit post too related to this. but seems like an older version of silentpatch fixed it for me. Maybe something related to that? or the skygfx mod doesnt fully properly support newest silentpatch?

Actually hold on, with "aap's skygfx" and my configs? does aap have some exclusive skygfx thingy ?

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

The latest SP enables directional lighting on detached car parts. Might be that something in SkyGfx Extended doesn't play nice with this.

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

The latest SP enables directional lighting on detached car parts. Might be that something in SkyGfx Extended doesn't play nice with this.

perhaps.. Could you please check ?

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

I cannot reproduce with Extended v1.7 either. There might be more to it than just the existence of those two mods. ImVehFt perhaps? image

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

I have ImVehFt installed but not sure what i could do with it. i mean it worked fine before, not sure. i know that i just replaced the newer SP with an older version and now the issue is gone

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

I have ImVehFt installed but not sure what i could do with it. i mean it worked fine before, not sure. i know that i just replaced the newer SP with an older version and now the issue is gone

Without the incompatibility nailed down precisely, I can't do anything about it.

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

I have ImVehFt installed but not sure what i could do with it. i mean it worked fine before, not sure. i know that i just replaced the newer SP with an older version and now the issue is gone

Without the incompatibility nailed down precisely, I can't do anything about it.

just tested right now as well, you're right. ImVehFt causes that thing only with latest silentpatch. the older one a bit, works just fine tho

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

just tested right now as well, you're right. ImVehFt causes that thing only with latest silentpatch. the older one a bit, works just fine tho

Yeah, that sounds more plausible. I'll look into it but it might be something out of my control and for ImVehFt to fix.

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

just tested right now as well, you're right. ImVehFt causes that thing only with latest silentpatch. the older one a bit, works just fine tho

Yeah, that sounds more plausible. I'll look into it but it might be something out of my control and for ImVehFt to fix.

Could a toggleable option be a thing at least as a workaround to not have to resort to older version of SP? Also if you can, to contact the dude behind ImVEhFt. im not familiar with who owns each mod

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

That requires figuring out what happened first, and once that happens I might have a fix already.

MOnkeMan5009 commented 2 weeks ago

That requires figuring out what happened first, and once that happens I might have a fix already.

So, with these incompatibilities i noticed anything other than PC preset, made that bug occur. which likely meant the car rendering thingy for PC too. So anything other like ps2 mobile etc, was broken with it

CookiePLMonster commented 2 weeks ago

I opened https://github.com/CookiePLMonster/SilentPatch/issues/111 to keep track of it on my side.

RuesanG commented 1 week ago

I cannot reproduce with Extended v1.7 either. There might be more to it than just the existence of those two mods. ImVehFt perhaps? image

For me it only happens when I use auto mods that include ImVehFT functions like "https://kiloryumods.my.canva.site/revampedvehiclesproject#downloads-2"

Lethality5001 commented 1 week ago

I cannot reproduce with Extended v1.7 either. There might be more to it than just the existence of those two mods. ImVehFt perhaps? image

For me it only happens when I use auto mods that include ImVehFT functions like "https://kiloryumods.my.canva.site/revampedvehiclesproject#downloads-2"

yeah, seems like silent said hes working on some compatibility fix

CookiePLMonster commented 1 week ago

I cannot reproduce with Extended v1.7 either. There might be more to it than just the existence of those two mods. ImVehFt perhaps? image

For me it only happens when I use auto mods that include ImVehFT functions like "https://kiloryumods.my.canva.site/revampedvehiclesproject#downloads-2"

Is the "public" version enough to reproduce the issue?

Lethality5001 commented 1 week ago

I cannot reproduce with Extended v1.7 either. There might be more to it than just the existence of those two mods. ImVehFt perhaps? image

For me it only happens when I use auto mods that include ImVehFT functions like "https://kiloryumods.my.canva.site/revampedvehiclesproject#downloads-2"

Is the "public" version enough to reproduce the issue?

yeah.

CookiePLMonster commented 1 week ago

I cannot reproduce with Extended v1.7 either. There might be more to it than just the existence of those two mods. ImVehFt perhaps? image

For me it only happens when I use auto mods that include ImVehFT functions like "https://kiloryumods.my.canva.site/revampedvehiclesproject#downloads-2"

Is the "public" version enough to reproduce the issue?

yeah.

Excellent, that'll be a good baseline for me to test with.