"Drive does not support READ CD" when dumping disc with audio track stored as data track

tjanas commented 2 years ago

Version

5.3.0

Commit hash

No response

Tested debug version?

[X] Yes

Which operating systems have you used?

[X] Windows
[ ] Linux
[ ] macOS
[ ] Other

What is the architectural bit size you're using?

[ ] 32-bit
[X] 64-bit
[ ] Unsure or unknown

What processor are you using?

[X] An Intel or AMD
[ ] An ARM or Apple Silicon
[ ] Unsure or unknown

Device manufacturer

ASUS

Device model

BW-16D1HT

Bus the device uses to attach to the computer

[ ] Parallel ATA
[ ] Serial ATA
[ ] SCSI (any)
[ ] ATAPI (mark above if parallel or serial)
[X] USB
[ ] FireWire
[ ] PCMCIA
[ ] SecureDigital
[ ] MultiMediaCard

USB cable or card reader manufacturer

OWC

USB cable or card reader model

Mercury Pro 5.25" Optical Drive External Enclosure

What were you doing when it failed?

[X] I was dumping media (disk, tape, etc)...
[ ] I was retrieving media (disk, tape, etc) information...
[ ] I was scanning media (disk, tape, etc)...
[ ] I was retrieving device information...

Description

My copy of the audio CD "Monster Magnet - Dopes To Infinity" has a data track 0, and an audio track 1 masquerading as a data track. I am unable to dump this disc successfully with Aaru.

Exact command line used

aaru.exe media dump -d -v --force True F: monster.aaruf

Expected behavior

I expected to be able to dump the disc successfully.

Actual behavior

Drive does not support READ CD, trying SCSI READ commands...
Checking if drive supports READ(6)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (6) took 4.0002 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(10)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (10) took 2462.1408 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(12)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (12) took 5803.332 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(16)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (16) took 4.0002 ms.
Cannot read from disc, not continuing...

Output of command execution with debug output enabled

aaru 5.3.0
Copyright c 2011-2021 Natalia Portillo

DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --cicm-xml=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --debug=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --device=F:
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --encoding=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --first-pregap=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-offset=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --force=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --format=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --metadata=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --options=
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --output=monster.aaruf
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --persistent=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --resume=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --retry-passes=5
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --skip=512
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --stop-on-error=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --trim=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --verbose=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --subchannel=any
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --private=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel-position=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --retry-subchannel=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --fix-subchannel-crc=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --generate-subchannels=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --skip-cdiready-hole=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --eject=False
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --max-blocks=64
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --use-buffered-reads=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --store-encrypted=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): --title-keys=True
DEBUG (Dump-Media command): Parsed options:
DEBUG (SCSI Device): INQUIRY took 2.0001 ms.
DEBUG (ATA Device): IDENTIFY PACKET DEVICE took 1 ms.
DEBUG (SCSI Device): GET CONFIGURATION (Starting Feature Number: 264, Return Type: Single, Sense: False, Last Error: 0) took 2.0002 ms.
Output image format: Aaru Format (49360069-1784-4a2f-b723-0c844d610b0a).
Device in database since 9/23/2020 4:37:21 AM.
DEBUG (SCSI Device): TEST UNIT READY took 1 ms.

DEBUG (SCSI Device): GET CONFIGURATION (Starting Feature Number: 0, Return Type: Current, Sense: False, Last Error: 0) took 1.0001 ms.
DEBUG (SCSI Device): MODE SENSE(10) took 2.0001 ms.
Reading full TOC
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ TOC/PMA/ATIP took (MSF: True, Format: 2, Track/Session Number: 0, Sense: False, LastError: 0) 5.0003 ms.
Building track map...
Checking if drive supports PQ subchannel reading...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 13531, Block Size: 2368, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True,
 Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: Q16, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 5739.3282 ms.
Checking if drive supports full raw subchannel reading...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 13531, Block Size: 2448, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True,
 Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: Raw, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 3162.1808 ms.
Checking if drive supports reading without subchannel...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ CD (LBA: 13531, Block Size: 2352, Transfer Length: 1, Expected Sector Type: AllTypes, DAP: False, Relative Address: False, Sync: True,
 Headers: AllHeaders, User Data: True, ECC/EDC: True, C2: None, Subchannel: None, Sense: True, Last Error: 0) took 3561.2036 ms.
Drive does not support READ CD, trying SCSI READ commands...
Checking if drive supports READ(6)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (6) took 4.0002 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(10)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (10) took 2462.1408 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(12)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (12) took 5803.332 ms.
Checking if drive supports READ(16)...
DEBUG (SCSI Device): READ (16) took 4.0002 ms.
Cannot read from disc, not continuing...

Media details

https://www.discogs.com/release/3203957-Monster-Magnet-Dopes-To-Infinity Files produced from media info -w 699: 699.zip

tjanas commented 2 years ago

Media info: monster_magnet_info.txt

tjanas commented 2 years ago

Catalog number on spine: 31454 0315 2 On disc label:

D108321
(31454 0315-2)

Disc pressing info: matrix: 3145403152 06% mastering SID: IFPI L007 mould SID (data side): IFPI 0350 inner hub (data side): MADE IN USA BY PMDC

TheRogueArchivist commented 2 years ago

Found a copy that doesn't exhibit this odd behavior, track 1 is audio and not data. Catalog number on spine: 31454 0315 2 Serial on label: 31454 0315 2 ADV Barcode: 7 31454-0315-2 3 Pressing info: Ringcode/matrix: 314 540 315 2AD V 01@ Mastering SID: IFPI L006 Mould SID: IFPI 0348 Additional mould: MADE IN USA BY PMDC

aaru-dps / Aaru