search

aboutcode-org / license-expression

Utility library to parse, normalize and compare License expressions for Python using a boolean logic engine. For expressions using SPDX or any other license id scheme.
http://aboutcode.org
Other
56 stars 23 forks source link

Deploy an online tool #18

Open alisianoi opened 7 years ago

alisianoi commented 7 years ago

This issue will capture progress on making license-expression and boolean.py into online tools.

Transpiling tools that did not quite work:

  1. RapydScript https://github.com/atsepkov/RapydScript Lacks support for importing things (like, import __future__), its list of importable modules is here

  2. Batavia https://github.com/pybee/batavia The idea here is to compile python to its bytecode and then run it in a javascript vm. Because python bytecode changes from version to version, batavia currently supports 3.4.4 and possibly 3.5.x (their docs state many things). My problem was compiling those pythons on Archlinux and when I finally did a) their test suite did not quite pass and b) it chocked on import __future__.

  3. PyPyJS https://github.com/pypyjs/pypyjs The whole thing is complicated and I failed to make it work. Main demotivator: the website offers python 2.7.9 and there is a github issue that indicates python 3 support is stalling.

Transpiling tools that look promising:

  1. Transcrypt https://github.com/qquick/Transcrypt and http://transcrypt.org This is currently the only candidate that has a distinct transpiling step (you actually see the .js files as a result) that could be made to work. However, there are problems which are summarized on SO.

  2. Brython https://github.com/brython-dev/brython The most laid-back approach: just works, delivers results but sometimes the resulting boolean expressions come out wrong (runtime error).

Transpiling tools that look promising but not yet tried:

  1. Skulpt http://www.skulpt.org/ It looks similar to Brython, which is why untried.

  2. flexx https://github.com/zoofIO/flexx

  3. https://github.com/alehander42/pseudo-python

  4. https://github.com/alehander42/pseudo

alisianoi commented 7 years ago

Need to watch a PyCon17 talk on building transpilers, might be useful:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9c4DEYIXYCM

pombredanne commented 7 years ago

and the pybee tool from the same author, that you listed alright :) great finds!

motet-a commented 7 years ago

Hello,

spdx-expression-parse is a SPDX expression parser written in JavaScript. There are other related packages in jslicense.

It is much more minimal than this project (which have many more features), but if it can save you some time...

pombredanne commented 7 years ago

@motet-a Thanks! spdx-expression-parse is great... with the caveat that the features it misses are the ones we want in JS ;) e.g. flexible parsing from eventually non-SPDX licenses names or ids, and boolean reasoning, sorting, simplification and equivalence on expressions. (FYI this effort to port this to JS by @all3fox is a GSoC project)

veer11997 commented 5 years ago

i would like to work on the project for gsoc 2019.and i want to contribute on it.