abrensch / brouter

configurable OSM offline router with elevation awareness, Java + Android
MIT License
490 stars 118 forks source link

Gebäude wird nicht angezeigt - Building is not shown #533

Closed guegafue closed 1 year ago

guegafue commented 1 year ago

In OpenStreetmap wird ein Gebäude, das es seit vielen Jahren gibt, nicht angezeigt. Relativ neue Gebäude dagegen schon. In TopPlusOpen wird das Bestandgebäude angezeigt, jedoch die neueren nicht. Liegt das evtl. daran, dass die in OpenStreetMap nicht angezeigten Gebäude mit Building:part erfasst wurden, die angezeigten mit Building=yes?

In OpenStreetmap, a building that has been there for many years is not shown. Relatively new buildings, on the other hand, do. In TopPlusOpen, the existing building is displayed, but the newer ones are not. Is this possibly because the buildings not shown in OpenStreetMap were recorded with Building:part and the ones shown with Building=yes?

2023-04-17_111548 2023-04-17_111614

nrenner commented 1 year ago

Not really a brouter question, but still:

Yes, I think the standard OSM layer doesn't render building:part. The wiki recommends:

building:part= areas should always be within a separate building= area representing the entire building.

https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:building:part

That building outline in way 277031322 was deleted in changeset 133914911 (OSMCha), including address and other information. So I think that way should be restored.

TopPlusOpen shows an old state as of 12/2022 (see "Aktuelle Änderungen") and is only updated once a year.