Review script for paper "2023ApJ...952....7Z" made with predictor "DataLinkerWithSupport"

abuonomo commented 4 months ago

Created by Paper Data Linking Bot

Please review the download script and instrument details for the paper.

bibcode: 2023ApJ...952....7Z predictor: DataLinkerWithSupport annotated pdf: view here (requires login)

Checklist

Download Script

[x] Correct time ranges specified
[x] Correct VSO instruments specified
[x] Query returns good results or contains warning with reasoning if not
[x] Physical observables omitted or correct
[x] Wavelengths omitted or correct
[x] Cadences omitted or correct

Instrument Details

[x] Consistent with download_script.py

Metadata

[x] Contains the bibcode for the relevant paper
[x] VSO sources consistent with download_script.py

For more details, refer to the Contributing Guide.

catbyrd commented 2 months ago

LASCO/SOHO did also mention using "the graduated cylindrical shell model to estimate the Physical Obvs the script found. And the annontated PDF picked it up as a PhysObv. But I am assuming that is just a tool used to find the PhysObvs and not an actual PhysObv itself.

catbyrd commented 2 months ago

All the information the script predicted for the CO1 and CO2 coronagraphs on STEREO-A and STEREO-B is all the same information it picked up for LASCO/SOHO. The annontated PDF did not pick up any information for CO1 & 2 on STEREO A & B, so I can't validate is this is correct without taking the time to read the entire 43 page document.

abuonomo / paper-data-links