Review script for paper "2023A&A...675A.136M" made with predictor "DataLinkerOptimizedRefine"

abuonomo commented 3 months ago

Created by Paper Data Linking Bot

Please review the download script and instrument details for the paper.

bibcode: 2023A&A...675A.136M predictor: DataLinkerOptimizedRefine (gpt-4o-mini) annotated pdf: view here (requires login)

Checklist

Download Script

[x] Correct time ranges specified
[x] Correct VSO instruments specified
[x] Query returns good results or contains warning with reasoning if not
[x] Physical observables omitted or correct
[x] Wavelengths omitted or correct
[x] Cadences omitted or correct

Instrument Details

[x] Consistent with download_script.py

Metadata

[x] Contains the bibcode for the relevant paper
[x] VSO sources consistent with download_script.py

For more details, refer to the Contributing Guide.

abuonomo commented 3 months ago

# Time range for CME1 observed by SECCHI
cme1_secchi_start = datetime(2014, 9, 9, 0, 24)
cme1_secchi_end = datetime(2014, 9, 9, 0, 24)  # Single observation

# Time range for CME2 observed by SECCHI
cme2_secchi_start = datetime(2014, 9, 10, 18, 24)
cme2_secchi_end = datetime(2014, 9, 10, 18, 24)  # Single observation

^ no time elapsed here, hence no results from these queries.

abuonomo commented 3 months ago

Wind and EUHFORIA correctly included in the instrument details and left out of the download script. Interesting that it knew to omit these non-VSO sources. Maybe following prompt to only use the instruments present in VSO interface info.

abuonomo commented 3 months ago

Missing AIA and HMI instruments. Maybe just due to using mini? Or maybe needs more comprehensive solution.

In section 3.1:

In this section, the pre-, during and post-eruptive magnetic field signatures are analysed with remote sensing observations from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) and Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) on board the Solar Disk Observatory (SDO; Lemen et al. 2012).

abuonomo / paper-data-links