search

acaudwell / Gource

software version control visualization
https://gource.io
GNU General Public License v3.0
11.45k stars 723 forks source link

Potential license violation in GitHub Marketplace #276

Closed patrickklaeren closed 2 years ago

patrickklaeren commented 2 years ago

Hi - apologies if this is not the right forum to discuss this.

I came across this app which markets itself to produce visual representation of repositories. Screenshots are clearly of Gource. They do not disclose this anywhere or disclose the source anywhere.

https://github.com/marketplace/visual-source

Happy to report this, but it seems as though the options via GitHub UI are a bit vague. Wanted to check here before.

mschilli87 commented 2 years ago

IANAL but are you sure they violoate the GPLv3 with this? Did you request the source code from them? Also, I am not sure if the GPL even covers this (unlike AGPL) since AFAICT they are running the software on 'their' server so you are being charged (if at all) for the service of running some software (looks like gource, I agree, but how does it matter) and giving you access to the video. What requirements does the GLP have for this use case that they don't meet?

acaudwell commented 2 years ago

I found on their website it does actually refer to using Gource here: https://www.visualsource.net/docs

@mschilli87's interpretation sounds about right to me. I think we would need to use a license like the AGPL to stop people making Gource as a service (GaaS) websites. Might be an opportunity there for someone to have an officially endorsed one...

Thanks for raising it though.