acl-org / aclrollingreview

ACL Rolling Review website
https://aclrollingreview.org
MIT License
9 stars 60 forks source link

Author page: Consider linking to advice on author response, revision explanation #95

Open nschneid opened 1 year ago

nschneid commented 1 year ago

I think some tutorials are out there that walk through how author responses are used and give more guidance—e.g., that the author response should be respectful of reviewers' efforts and aim to provide helpful clarifications/corrections.

For explanations of revisions, it would be helpful to provide an example or template (#23). https://transacl.org/index.php/tacl/about/submissions has a template for TACL.

nschneid commented 1 year ago

Guide on writing rebuttals: https://deviparikh.medium.com/how-we-write-rebuttals-dc84742fece1

ACL 2023 blog post: https://2023.aclweb.org/blog/review-basics/#6-author-response Not sure all the advice there applies to ARR (do we want to encourage all authors to respond, or just if there is something substantive to say?) but it's a starting point.