acmsigsoft / EmpiricalStandards

Tools and standards for conducting and evaluating research in software engineering
https://acmsigsoft.github.io/EmpiricalStandards/
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
294 stars 62 forks source link

Custom follow-ups and error flows #16

Open drpaulralph opened 3 years ago

drpaulralph commented 3 years ago

As an editor (of the standards)

I want to write custom follow-up questions for some, but not all, essential criteria,

So that I can better guide reviewer decision-making.

For example, if a reviewer clicks 'no' to "discusses implications of the results", right now the system asks "is this deviation reasonable," but I would like it to display a text box where the reviewer can list important limitations that are missing or explain why the limitations listed are incorrect. This is just an example. What I'm after is a simple way of specifying these follow up questions (e.g., in mardown files) without hardcoding them in javascript.

drpaulralph commented 8 months ago

@Terry-One Has implemented this for the one-stage checklist but not the two-stage checklist.