Open giacomo-petri opened 3 months ago
I'll also seize this opportunity to eliminate Failed Example 6, as it duplicates Failed Example 5.
Failed Example 6 has already been removed via a previous PR, rendering the previous comment unnecessary.
@Jym77 @carlosapaduarte, regarding my initial point, I'd like to hear your thoughts. While addressing this, I noticed that other links are also outdated, with anchors no longer functional.
I'm contemplating whether it would be prudent to redirect all these links to the "previous" (it's still the current official one) version of CSS Device Adaptation Module Level 1 or if we should amend the rule based on the new CSS Viewport Module Level 1 working draft. However, considering the meta is specific to older devices, perhaps the rule no longer holds relevance if we point to the new documentation.
Currently, the links within the notes of the Expectations section of Meta viewport allows for zoom rule, direct to the wrong resource: https://www.w3.org/TR/css-viewport-1/, where the algorithm differs significantly from the one used to calculate failing examples.
The new algorithm is as follows: Set-Property matches the listed property names case-insensitively. The property-value strings are interpreted as follows:
In contrast, the previous algorithm operated as follows:
Given that the rule is tailored to old devices (as newer devices typically ignore settings like user-scalable:no and maximum-scale:1), it seems necessary to point to the specific version of the CSS Device Adaptation Module Level 1. Without this specificity, the current wording of the rule lacks coherence.
If you concur with this assessment, I'm happy to create a PR to implement these amendments.