adam-mcdaniel / capitalist-chess

An engine for a chess variant which adds banks🏦 and a market📈!
MIT License
47 stars 5 forks source link

A King being purchaseable complicates the game somewhat #1

Open sokorototo opened 5 months ago

sokorototo commented 5 months ago

Given that you can buy a King, you can have multiple Kings on the board. Do you lose when any of your kings are checkmated, or do you have a primary King? Don't you think the idea of Chess is that while many things can happen on the deck, the main objective is a checkmate? If there are multiple ways to get a checkmate, doesn't that make the game chaotic, in a very non-chess manner?

adam-mcdaniel commented 5 months ago

This is a good point, I was considering removing this myself before I pushed the crate

Buying a King should be in response to a siege that can't be defended against. Maybe checkmate should only apply when all kings are guaranteed to be captured, but that would really draw out the game

I do like the idea of there only being one King on the board at a time, if players should be able to buy a King at all, maybe there should only be two so that the player can create one before the other is captured, so the game can continue

I think the cleanest solution would be to remove purchasing Kings entirely, that would be the most elegant and reduce the complexity of an already complex variant

sokorototo commented 5 months ago

Yeah, removing the ability to purchase Kings is the most straightforward solution. But you could have an election mechanic, that allows you to teleport the King to a safer position.