adeekshith / watomatic

Auto reply app to enable auto reply for messengers like WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger
https://watomatic.app
GNU General Public License v3.0
441 stars 87 forks source link

Watomatic doesn't work on some Xiaomi devices #134

Open pixincreate opened 3 years ago

pixincreate commented 3 years ago

ISSUE: Fails to work on Xiaomi device

Well, as said above, the app works fine on Xiaomi device with a major flaw.
It doesn't Reply to any of the incoming messages.

May be, it's due to, different notification channel which is different from other OEMs, used by Xiaomi on its software MIUI as usual.

Device Specifications:

adeekshith commented 3 years ago

Hi, thanks for reporting this with device specs. Yeah that is very much necessary to know as the app does not have built in analytics (for a good reason). Not all but a few Xiomi models may have this problem. Will try to figure out a way to eliminate bad apples and make it unavailable on play store.

@spuday90 was using Redmi Android 10 device to test the app and it was working there. @spuday90 mind sharing your device specs?

spuday90 commented 3 years ago

My device is Mi 10i Android 10 MiUi 12.0.4

Also my other device is Redmi note 5 pro

adeekshith commented 3 years ago

Here is an idea. We can perhaps write some code to detect if it was able to successfully send a reply. The app should reply to the notification as it normally does and then test if the notification still exists. If notification still exists, it means the reply mechanism did not work. By the above logic if we detect it is not able to reply, we can show an error to the user and ask them to submit it.

As we keep getting sufficient data, we can consider making the app unavailable for those devices.

Should try this and see if it works. Feel free to add your ideas if any.

daniel-alomar commented 3 years ago

I have a Xiaomi Mi 10 and had the same issue.. Mi 10 Android 11 MIUI 12.2.4

Can we test it without depending other user to send us a message?

FriedrichGaming commented 3 years ago

Same issue... Redmi Note 4 Android 7 MIUI 11.0.2

Update (20.05.2021): It seems to work now.

KiezKrieger commented 3 years ago

Hi, Reply for WhatsApp works, but not for FB Messenger (original and lite). Redmi Note 7 Android 10 MIUI 12.0.3.0 extended by Nova Launcher