adipiciu / Travian-scripts

Userscripts for Travian. Resource bar plus. Wave builder. Task queue.
GNU General Public License v3.0
38 stars 23 forks source link

Total Oasis Supply Point in Neighbors List #70

Closed mchdgrd closed 3 months ago

mchdgrd commented 3 months ago

I use neighbors list below map when i want to increase my hero's xp. However, i always need to hover over to see the total oasis supply point in each oasis in the list.

Improving this feature would solve the mentioned issue.

This is how it will look like: image

mchdgrd commented 3 months ago

Additionally, we can also relocate the info button to the right side of the wild animals section, next to the supply point.

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

The script version needs to be change in both files (meta.js and user.js). But for one change, there is no reason to modify the version. I can update the version with a new script release.

About the change, I can move the tooltip at the end. But the total crop number is not always useful, you need to see the total defense vs total crop ratio to be more efficient and have few troop losses. That number in pink can be misleading, not everybody knows what it means. We need to discuss how this can be improved and displayed.

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

What about this? image

mchdgrd commented 3 months ago

I was not sure about version. version was updated in previous merge. Its because i changed. You know the job :)

Adding only colored number may cause some misunderstanding as you said. new line is more useful. but it may also confuse oasis ratio with supply. but there is no sign else to show the crop number i think. total defense point is also looks important. cant we put all total row from tooltip? or maybe just only crop number and total cage number.

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

I was thinking about placing the total row, but it is too much info, it clutters all the space.

mchdgrd commented 3 months ago

I updated my side as I committed. It meets my needs. Others opinions are important. But this version is even good

kikuman commented 3 months ago

can you also add the defense vs total crop ratio? this info is greatly needed.

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

Is this ok? Or do you want also the total crop to be displayed? Bigger ratio number is better, but some oasis have less animals, so to be more efficient in case of same ratio, we need to know which oasis has more animal crop consumption. image

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

Should we show the crop separately, or can we find a mathematic formulae to include the bigger crop value in the result?

image

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

Also, if you have many troops, you don't care about the ratio, you want only the biggest crop number.

mchdgrd commented 3 months ago

Total crop number is important. Ratio looks also important. Last image you sended is works for us i think

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

image or is this icon better for hero xp?

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

Total crop number is important. Ratio looks also important. Last image you sended is works for us i think

Choose one of the last 2 images :)

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

That crop icon looks similar to the oasis crop bonus icon and can be confusing.

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

I added a header, to remove all the clutter from the same icons repeated on every line image

adipiciu commented 3 months ago

Added in 2.24.10