adobe-fonts / source-han-sans

Source Han Sans | 思源黑体 | 思源黑體 | 思源黑體 香港 | 源ノ角ゴシック | 본고딕
Other
14.48k stars 1.3k forks source link

Issue with HK U+5D6B 嵫 and U+6ECB 滋 #486

Open NightFurySL2001 opened 9 months ago

NightFurySL2001 commented 9 months ago

U+5D6B 嵫 is a Big5 level 2 character. A new glyph is required for HK. It can then be mapped to KR following code chart (?). image Affects Serif as well. image

滋 U+6ECB requires a new HK glyph too. Same for Serif. image image image In EDB: image

NightFurySL2001 commented 6 months ago

[Main issue is updated with U+6ECB 滋.]

It seems that characters in Big5 that had a variant of 茲 in HKSCS shows up as 兹 in EDB.

孳 U+5B73 (Big5) vs 孶 U+5B76 (HKSCS) image image

慈 U+6148 (Big5) vs 慈 U+2F8A6 (HKSCS) image image

磁 U+78C1 (Big5) vs 𥔵 U+25535 (HKSCS) image image

Reference Glyphs for Chinese Computer Systems in Hong Kong (2016) show U+5D6B 嵫 and 滋 U+6ECB used 兹. However in the latest code charts, these 2 glyphs have been changed to use 茲. This seem to be done in Unicode 13.0 without any IRG documents. image image

Otherwise, the characters (no matter Big5 or HKSCS) uses 茲, not 兹.

hfhchan commented 6 months ago

I am reposting this because I realized I posted this under the wrong account. @NightFurySL2001 was responding to this post previously.

[Previously posted comment starts below]

I would suggest putting this character change on hold, because the Education Bureau of Hong Kong can't even decide on a consistent shape. See 孳: image

vs 慈: image

Meanwhile, both Ping Fang HK and most commerically available fonts use 兹 instead of 茲.

hfhchan commented 6 months ago

Yes I am aware most glyphs for Reference Glyphs for Chinese Computer Systems in Hong Kong (2016) have been updated to use the grass head, but practically all the commerical fonts produced for Hong Kong do not use this shape.

I will be writing a document to CLIAC shortly after I gather all relevant materials and evidences, so I would advise Adobe to temporarily put this on hold before it is sorted out.