adobe-fonts / source-han-serif

Source Han Serif | 思源宋体 | 思源宋體 | 思源宋體 香港 | 源ノ明朝 | 본명조
https://adobe.ly/SourceHanSerif
Other
8.16k stars 644 forks source link

莁(U+8381) and 菄(U+83C4) has wrong radical 艹 for CN #200

Closed CrotchBurnt closed 1 year ago

CrotchBurnt commented 1 year ago

image

Marcus98T commented 1 year ago

A similar issue has been reported for Sans in 2021.

Unfortunately due to limited glyph space, some CN glyphs will show JP or TW/HK forms as the only glyph shape for CN, although most of them are rare-use characters which may not reflect actual usage in China. Most of those affected glyphs are GB Extension characters, although some of them, in the case of showing TW/HK forms, are G3 or G5 characters according to the Unicode charts.

When I'm free, I will list down all the CN glyphs showing JP forms and TW/HK forms for Serif in a separate issue.

punchcutter commented 1 year ago

These glyphs only have a TW form right now and no current plan to add a CN glyph without some compelling argument.

Marcus98T commented 1 year ago

and no current plan to add a CN glyph without some compelling argument.

@punchcutter I see.

Which is why I suggest that the Sans and Serif readmes should add a note that not all GB 18030 characters are CN-compliant. That way people at least can know that Adobe is aware of this issue and may probably address it with a major redesign, or will not be addressing it due to technical limitations.

Sorry to bring it up again and again.