search

aesculus / denonavpcontrol

LMS plugin for Denon/Marrantz receivers
14 stars 6 forks source link

Set source on play #14

Closed bjarteskogoy closed 3 years ago

bjarteskogoy commented 3 years ago

It would be nice if the plugin could reset the input source when you play something. Maybe the receiver has been used for something else in the meantime.

If the repo could be set up with the source not only as a zip I could submit a PR.

aesculus commented 3 years ago

It supports the Quick Select (1-3). That will reset the source if you turn the player off/on.

The source is in the zip file.

bjarteskogoy commented 3 years ago

I have one receiver which supports quick select and an older Marantz which does not. It would be nice if we could get the change "wagner-ch" did, as a pull request.

A lot of the time the receiver has been used for TV-audio or something else in between playing music. It would be nice if pressing play re-selected the input source, select input or quick select, instead of having to turn the squeezebox off and on to get the correct input.

aesculus commented 3 years ago

I understand why the input may need to be reset and can consider other than the Quick Select.

But I am not sure why this needs to be done at every play. Why is it not appropriate to do this only when the player is turned on?

bjarteskogoy commented 3 years ago

I have already implemented the input select, https://github.com/bjarteskogoy/denonavpcontrol

But I have not looked into making sure the receiver is on when you start playing.

aesculus commented 3 years ago

We are going to look at adding this in the next release after 3.0 which is pending any day now.

aesculus commented 3 years ago

After reviewing this request we felt that it was too unique and would not be utilized by enough users to justify the effort. We were also worried that it could cause confusion and problems that we would have to deal with.

Since you have a working solution we felt it was best to have you continue doing what you do. Note that version 4.0 will probably be the last for awhile so if you concentrate on updating your process for that version you should be safe.