[Feature] Phoenix HTML 4.0 not supported

[nathany-copia]

Versions Used Kaffy: 0.10.2 Phoenix: 1.7.10 Elixir: 1.16.0

What's actually happening?

==> kaffy
Compiling 26 files (.ex)

== Compilation error in file lib/kaffy/resource_error.ex ==
** (RuntimeError) use Phoenix.HTML is no longer supported in v4.0.

To keep compatibility with previous versions, add {:phoenix_html_helpers, "~> 1.0"} to your mix.exs deps
and then, instead of "use Phoenix.HTML", you might:

    import Phoenix.HTML
    import Phoenix.HTML.Form
    use PhoenixHTMLHelpers

What should happen instead?

Update for Phoenix HTML 4.0 https://hexdocs.pm/phoenix_html/changelog.html

Screenshots If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem.

[drobban]

Well. Not sure if this is to classify as a bug.

Im running Kaffy: 0.10.2 Phoenix: 1.7.10 Phoenix_live_view: 0.20.3 Phoenix_html: 3.3 Elixir: 1.16.0

and I have not encountered the runtime error you have - Trying to upgrade to Phoenix_html: 4.0 is stopped - as kaffy depend on Phoenix_html: 3.x

Bumping the version of Phoenix_html: 3.x to 4.x in kaffy - I guess the solution then is to do what the changelog and runtime error suggest. Change the use of Phoenix.HTML to import...... and add the dependency phoenix_html_helpers, "~> 1.0"

import Phoenix.HTML
import Phoenix.HTML.Form
use PhoenixHTMLHelpers

I dont have any plans to bump up to phoenix_html 4.0 in any current project for the moment. Perhaps this would be a perfect moment for you to test making the change in kaffy repo - bumping the versions and make a pull request?

Otherwise, test to downgrade Phoenix_html and follow the instructions in the readme.

Happy hunting.

[nathany-copia]

We can just continue to use Phoenix HTML 3.3 for now.

I updated the title to classify it as a feature request, but I can't modify the label myself.

[drobban]

@nathany-copia I made a pull-request solving the issue you reported!

Would be awesome if you could test it out and report back if you find any bugs/errors. Pull request #306

To test run it you can change your dep in mix.exs to use {:kaffy, git: "https://github.com/drobban/kaffy.git", branch: "phx_1.7.10_breaking"},

update If you want to test it out use this line instead and reference a specific commit instead {:kaffy, github: "drobban/kaffy", ref: "fd0ee0b"}

[nathany-copia]

Thank you @drobban.

My server and tests are all working after updating a few spots from use Phoenix.HTML to the following:

import Phoenix.HTML
import Phoenix.HTML.Form
use PhoenixHTMLHelpers

Though I must admit, I'm not using Kaffy very heavily, but what I saw continued to work.

I used the line {:kaffy, github: "drobban/kaffy", ref: "fd0ee0b"} in mix.exs because I like to lock down the commit being pulled in.

[drobban]

@nathany-copia Smart move 😅 didn't really think so much about until now after you mentioned it. Pinning to commit is definitely safer and less risk of headaches.

[phortx]

Hi! Any plans to merge and release that change? :)

[drobban]

Hi! Any plans to merge and release that change? :)

Would guess that @aesmail will have a look at it when he has time over for it. At mean time, it would be great if you could test that change out and report back - Super simple to do, just specify the commit in your deps list. =)

[phortx]

@drobban thanks for the answer :) I plan to test that branch in the next week and give you feedback :)

[drobban]

@phortx as @nathany-copia pointed out

"I used the line {:kaffy, github: "drobban/kaffy", ref: "fd0ee0b"} in mix.exs because I like to lock down the commit being pulled in."

Is a much smarter move then to use branch as I did in my example... In that way you wont be surprissed by any changes in that branch that I might make.

[nathany-copia]

It's probably best to make a fork and use that. Otherwise the branch (and commit) could be deleted (such as when merged) and break the build.

[antonioparisi]

is this repo still maintained?

[drobban]

is this repo still maintained?

it is as far as i know. Why do you ask?

[estromenko]

Any updates?

[drobban]

Any updates?

I guess if there where any to report, you would of seen it in the relevant issue topic.

Feel free to read this until there is any updates. https://github.com/sponsors/aesmail

You can also test the pull request solving this issue by starting using it and report back if everything works as intended.

Instructions is found in the thread.

[ghenry]

We've merged a fix for this. Please re-test.

[murraybryant]

works for me now

[nathany-copia]

Thank you.

I'm using {:kaffy, github: "aesmail/kaffy", ref: "d864ea1"} which is working here.