search

agroportal / project-management

Repository used to consolidate documentation about the AgroPortal project and track content related issues.
http://agroportal.lirmm.fr
7 stars 0 forks source link

Metadata : abstract #236

Closed saubin78 closed 10 months ago

saubin78 commented 2 years ago

What would be the difference between "abstract" and "description" ? What information is expected in each ? I'd suggest removing "abstract" which brings confusion

jonquet commented 2 years ago

Strangely the 2 properties come from DCT. Dublin Core might have judge that they could be potentially useful. So I did certainly in 2016.

Abstract | DCTERMS: A summary of the resource.

Description | DCTERMS: An account of the resource. Description may include but is not limited to: an abstract, a table of contents, a graphical representation, or a free-text account of the resource.OMV: Free text description of an ontology.

In AgroPortal, We have been using the abstract field several times: http://data.agroportal.lirmm.fr/submissions/?display=description,abstract&display_links=false&display_context=false

Could you revise and precise your opinion? I am not strongly in favour of keeping "abstract" but then what would we do for the ontologies using it.

saubin78 commented 2 years ago

Looking at data shows that people tend to provide more detailed information in Abstract. One way to deal with this may be to enhance the contextual help (pop up when mouse over the question mark). "A summary of the ontology", indicate something like "Use this field to provide additional information about the ontology" In fact, we may consider changing several contextual help to facilitate the user filling the metadata. Instructions instead of a description of the metadata element may be more useful in a number of cases. See https://github.com/agroportal/project-management/issues/113 for instance Sophie

jonquet commented 2 years ago

Oui tout cela sera capturer dans le retactoring de la page Summary; https://github.com/ontoportal-lirmm/bioportal_web_ui/issues/75

syphax-bouazzouni commented 10 months ago

Oui tout cela sera capturer dans le retactoring de la page Summary; ontoportal-lirmm/bioportal_web_ui#75

Is it? if no . Please refine the work to be done, in a list of requirements.

jonquet commented 10 months ago

I was kind of ok to remove this property (at least from AgroPortal) untill I look a @hibadjebabria169 figure:

Values in AgroPortal: http://data.agroportal.lirmm.fr/submissions?&display=abstract Populated ratio: 37/159 => 23%

=> I would then leave it like this for now. Untill we have another set of remarks. In the new UI abstract will not be part of the main properties.