Closed snakedye closed 3 weeks ago
Since the connection is instantiated in the function, I don't know if I can rollback the changes. Otherwise if the test pass on the datastore it should mostly be fine here.
@snakedye @k-allagbe I have been working a bit on automating PR reviews for Cedille, my student club. We are starting to see somewhat decent results ... ish.
I tried to run this PR through the pipeline to see what we would get.
Let me know your first impressions tomorrow, which parts of the review are useful which parts are completely useless, etc.
PR Automated Review
Title: Enhancements to User Authentication and Form Management in Fertiscan Backend
Context:
/login
, /signup
) and comprehensive form management capabilities (/forms
endpoints for CRUD operations). It also includes improvements to logging, configuration management via environment variables, and updates to the Swagger documentation.Key Changes:
/login
and /signup
endpoints for user authentication.requirements.txt
.Specific Comments:
Environment Variables:
+FERTISCAN_STORAGE_URL=
+FERTISCAN_SCHEMA=
+FERTISCAN_DB_URL=
Comment: Consider adding default values or comments to explain the purpose of these environment variables for better clarity and maintainability. This helps new developers understand the required configurations. Suggestion:
+FERTISCAN_STORAGE_URL= # URL for the storage service
+FERTISCAN_SCHEMA=fertiscan_0.0.8 # Default schema version
+FERTISCAN_DB_URL= # Database connection URL
Error Handling in create_form
Endpoint:
+ return jsonify(error="Internal server error!"), HTTPStatus.INTERNAL_SERVER_ERROR
Comment: It's essential to avoid exposing internal error messages directly to the client. Consider logging the error and providing a generic error message to the client. Suggestion:
+ logger.error(f"Error occurred: {err}")
+ logger.error("Traceback: " + traceback.format_exc())
+ return jsonify(error="An unexpected error occurred. Please try again later."), HTTPStatus.INTERNAL_SERVER_ERROR
Password Management in signup
Endpoint:
+ _ = request.form.get("password")
Comment: Ensure that passwords are hashed and stored securely. This line should include password hashing before storing it in the database. Suggestion:
+ password = request.form.get("password")
+ hashed_password = hash_password(password) # Implement a secure hashing function
+ # Store the hashed password in the database
Asynchronous Database Operations:
+ user = asyncio.run(new_user(cursor, username, FERTISCAN_STORAGE_URL))
Comment: Using asyncio.run
is appropriate, but ensure that the database driver supports asynchronous operations to avoid potential issues.
Suggestion: Verify and document the compatibility of the database driver with asynchronous operations.
Logging Configuration:
+logging.basicConfig(
+ filename=log_file_path,
+ level=logging.INFO,
+ force=True,
+ format="%(asctime)s - %(name)s - %(levelname)s - %(message)s",
+)
Comment: Consider setting different logging levels for development and production environments to avoid excessive logging in production. Suggestion:
+log_level = os.getenv("LOG_LEVEL", "INFO")
+logging.basicConfig(
+ filename=log_file_path,
+ level=getattr(logging, log_level.upper(), logging.INFO),
+ force=True,
+ format="%(asctime)s - %(name)s - %(levelname)s - %(message)s",
+)
Swagger Documentation:
+ 500:
+ description: Internal Server Error
+ schema:
+ type: object
+ properties:
+ error:
+ type: string
+ example: "Internal server error"
Comment: Ensure that the Swagger documentation reflects all possible responses, including edge cases and specific error messages. Suggestion: Review and update the Swagger documentation to include detailed descriptions of all potential error responses for each endpoint.
General Cautions:
Approval Recommendation:
Related to #89 Closes #104 Closes #122