vivek: what is lost if we dump the current section 4+5?

ai-se / ResourcesDataDrivenSBSE

Other

4 stars 0 forks source link

vivek: what is lost if we dump the current section 4+5? #22

Closed timm closed 6 years ago

timm commented 6 years ago

if there is cool stuff there, move it forward.

(but do you see the two bold ital quotes on p2? i'd like to keep them on p2 ins we can)

otherwise, and excuse my hubris, i prefer my new p1,2,3

vivekaxl commented 6 years ago

I absolutely love the p1, 2, 3 and it is much better than my draft.

However, I think that it explains things so fast that a new guy (SBSE or MSR) would have a hard time understand what is going on. I think there is a need for a tutorial session or rather a slow introduction to the concepts. Some parts of current 5 and 6 can be used.

vivekaxl commented 6 years ago

Another comment: I felt that this paper was written to fit the 'data showcase' style rather than a research vision statement. Is that the intention?

timm commented 6 years ago

data showcase is 6 pages. we need to be a full paper
agreed. section2 ("what") needs a super brief description of multi-objective, pareto front, domination (which can lead to a superbrief description of hypervolume, spread, igd, gd)
all done before p3.
and table 2 can move to p3.
over to you

vivekaxl commented 6 years ago

I have summarized the content of Section 4 and 5 into a table Figure 2. Please review. @timm