search

ajslater / picopt

A multi format lossless image optimizer that uses external tools
GNU General Public License v3.0
108 stars 11 forks source link

Decreases File Size #3

Closed habakuk007 closed 6 years ago

habakuk007 commented 10 years ago

If used with jpegrescan the file size is increased:

albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Savinesti (20).JPG: 6.01% (70.9 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/CVJM_Cristuru (51).JPG: 2.01% (21.6 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_Dorf_Csekefalva (82).JPG: 5.57% (57.1 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_im_CVJM_Befalva (45).JPG: 6.49% (64.3 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_Dorf_Csekefalva (116).JPG: 5.70% (74.0 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_Dorf_Csekefalva (81).JPG: 6.34% (57.0 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_im_CVJM_Befalva (78).JPG: 3.55% (36.1 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Piatra_Neamt (45).JPG: 2.95% (30.9 kiB)
albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Schaessburg (5).JPG: 6.41% (57.2 kiB)

I had not a single decrease in file size.

ajslater commented 10 years ago

That log indicates that the images decreased in size between about 2 and 7% each if I'm reading that correctly.

Do another run with a test batch of images, list the files sizes before and after and compare.

picopt should also have given you a summary at the end for total bytes and % saved.

AJ

On Mon, Sep 15, 2014 at 1:47 PM, habakuk007 notifications@github.com wrote:

If used with jpegrescan the file size is increased:

albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Savinesti (20).JPG: 6.01% (70.9 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/CVJM_Cristuru (51).JPG: 2.01% (21.6 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_Dorf_Csekefalva (82).JPG: 5.57% (57.1 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_im_CVJM_Befalva (45).JPG: 6.49% (64.3 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_Dorf_Csekefalva (116).JPG: 5.70% (74.0 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_Dorf_Csekefalva (81).JPG: 6.34% (57.0 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Roma_im_CVJM_Befalva (78).JPG: 3.55% (36.1 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Piatra_Neamt (45).JPG: 2.95% (30.9 kiB) albums/cvjm-kornmarkt/internationale_arbeit/Romania-Mission-Trip-2013/Schaessburg (5).JPG: 6.41% (57.2 kiB)

I had not a single decrease in file size.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/ajslater/picopt/issues/3.

habakuk007 commented 10 years ago

Hi, thanks for your fast reply!

Probably was wrong as after the run there were many files like "...JPG.picopt-optimized.png" in the directory. After deleting them manually the size of the folder decreased again.

Also there is a different behavior if I use -r or not (if there are no subfolders). If I use it without I get the message "Didn't optimize any files." If I do use it every file is listed and some are optimized.

Best regard! Stefan

ajslater commented 10 years ago

the .picopt-optimized.png files are temporary files that should be cleaned up by picopt. If they're not, then picopt was interrupted or there's a bug.

$ picopt # does nothing. no files specified. $ picopt a.jpg b.png # optimizes two files. $ picopt * # will try to optimize everything in the directory (non recursive) $ picopt -r mydir # optimizes files in mydir recursilvely $ picopt -r # I think is the same as picopt -r .

AJ

On Mon, Sep 15, 2014 at 2:45 PM, habakuk007 notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi, thanks for your fast reply!

Probably was wrong as after the run there were many files like "...JPG.picopt-optimized.png" in the directory. After deleting them manually the size of the folder decreased again.

Also there is a different behavior if I use -r or not (if there are no subfolders). If I use it without I get the message "Didn't optimize any files." If I do use it every file is listed and some are optimized.

Best regard! Stefan

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/ajslater/picopt/issues/3#issuecomment-55663944.