xcode 9.2 Can you use it? - Githubissues

alcatraz / Alcatraz

Package manager for Xcode

alcatraz.io

MIT License

9.87k stars 1.15k forks source link

xcode 9.2 Can you use it? #524

Closed YHqihuan closed 6 years ago

YHqihuan commented 6 years ago

xcode 9.2 Can you use it?

manmanking commented 6 years ago

install sudo gem install update_xcode_plugins and update_xcode_plugins this plugin is working

mike-lischke commented 6 years ago

Not for me (XCode 9.3.1). Also update_xcode_plugins didn't help, the menu entry simply doesn't appear (though XCode asked me to load the bundle, which I agreed on).

jurre commented 6 years ago

It is not supported on iOS 9, it requires some hacks to unsign Xcode that we don't support.

mike-lischke commented 6 years ago

So why keeping this project up? You can delete it now to avoid having people trying for quite some time to get it running while looking for a solution.

alanhamlett commented 6 years ago

It's still being used by people who unsigned their Xcode.

For example, #498 and https://wakatime.com/xcode.

guillaumealgis commented 6 years ago

The very first line of the README states clearly that Alcatraz was designed for Xcode 7. A few lines down we added a statement in bold that Xcode 8+ is not supported, with a link to the issue where this compatibility problem is discussed.

Some people still find Alcatraz useful, I don't see why we should delete it.

mike-lischke commented 6 years ago

I see, I should have added the <irony> tag. First it is stated that this project doesn't support the only remaining solution (unsigning XCode) and next that solution is brought up as reason to keep this project up. Do you see the irony now?

guillaumealgis commented 6 years ago

@mike-lischke I think it all comes down to a communication problem, we should maybe do a better job at indicating the current state of the project.

I think @jurre was talking about the maintainers position on unsigning Xcode when he said "we don't support [it]". But Alcatraz does work once Xcode is unsigned (I haven't tested it myself, but others do use it).