some is_pending are true but should be false

[nicolasburtey]

doing a await lnService.getClosedChannels({lnd}) and looping over the close_payments array.

I have this result on one of the item:

  {
    ...
    close_transaction_id: '56606548dd251395d67a41a355bc54aa40d1061bb065e81c403815e3506c746d',
   ...
    close_payments: [
      {
        is_paid: false,
        spent_by: 'fcfd551b8dad977156399bb368f34bbb8ced5fbfb3c19f9360e5a90428bb01f2',
        transaction_id: 'd85f18f3755d85b2fb29f9331886c5e20c42749df7926c5202f6e21f41951047',
        is_pending: false,
        transaction_vout: 0,
        is_refunded: true,
        is_outgoing: true,
        tokens: 373777
      },
      {
        spent_by: '091eeaabecc9d5a7750c8032914ef52151fc25e9ecc3cb550322c0e4c1c755ad',
        transaction_id: '82ada5a715b24ac00dbc9ff7270a5aa701e899b7d83aea1846aafdb0283d3c52',
        is_paid: false,
        is_pending: false,
        tokens: 381093,
        is_refunded: true,
        transaction_vout: 0,
        is_outgoing: true
      },
      {
        is_refunded: false,
        transaction_vout: 0,
        tokens: 392171,
        is_pending: true,
        spent_by: 'd85f18f3755d85b2fb29f9331886c5e20c42749df7926c5202f6e21f41951047',
        is_outgoing: true,
        transaction_id: '56606548dd251395d67a41a355bc54aa40d1061bb065e81c403815e3506c746d',
        is_paid: false
      },
      {
        transaction_vout: 1,
        tokens: 399487,
        spent_by: '82ada5a715b24ac00dbc9ff7270a5aa701e899b7d83aea1846aafdb0283d3c52',
        is_paid: false,
        is_pending: true,
        transaction_id: '56606548dd251395d67a41a355bc54aa40d1061bb065e81c403815e3506c746d',
        is_outgoing: true,
        is_refunded: false
      }
    ],
   ...
  },

looking at the transaction, they have been mined ~6 months ago. and are still pending: true.

I don't know if this is a state issue in lnd, or if this is how Ln Service fetches the value that is not right?

[alexbosworth]

I'm not sure, pending in the result maps to "first stage" outcome in the response, normally when it was resolved it would map to "claimed" or "timeout"

[nicolasburtey]

do you know if there is a way to mitigate such issues? Worth opening a ticket on the main lnd repo? The issue happened probably 2 lnd version ago. I had the issue on 2 different channels.

As a workaround, is it possible to force delete the channel such that it no longer in the db?

[alexbosworth]

Can you paste the output of the lncli closedchannels to see if it is mapping ok?

[alexbosworth]

I don't think you can force delete a channel aside from abandonchannel

[nicolasburtey]

"resolutions": [
                {
                    "resolution_type": "OUTGOING_HTLC",
                    "outcome": "TIMEOUT",
                    "outpoint": {
                        "txid_bytes": "471095411fe2f602526c92f79d74420ce2c5861833f929fbb2855d75f3185fd8",
                        "txid_str": "d85f18f3755d85b2fb29f9331886c5e20c42749df7926c5202f6e21f41951047",
                        "output_index": 0
                    },
                    "amount_sat": "373777",
                    "sweep_txid": "fcfd551b8dad977156399bb368f34bbb8ced5fbfb3c19f9360e5a90428bb01f2"
                },
                {
                    "resolution_type": "OUTGOING_HTLC",
                    "outcome": "TIMEOUT",
                    "outpoint": {
                        "txid_bytes": "523c3d28b0fdaa4618ea3ad8b799e801a75a0a27f79fbc0dc04ab215a7a5ad82",
                        "txid_str": "82ada5a715b24ac00dbc9ff7270a5aa701e899b7d83aea1846aafdb0283d3c52",
                        "output_index": 0
                    },
                    "amount_sat": "381093",
                    "sweep_txid": "091eeaabecc9d5a7750c8032914ef52151fc25e9ecc3cb550322c0e4c1c755ad"
                },
                {
                    "resolution_type": "OUTGOING_HTLC",
                    "outcome": "FIRST_STAGE",
                    "outpoint": {
                        "txid_bytes": "6d746c50e31538401ce865b01b06d140aa54bc55a3417ad6951325dd48656056",
                        "txid_str": "56606548dd251395d67a41a355bc54aa40d1061bb065e81c403815e3506c746d",
                        "output_index": 0
                    },
                    "amount_sat": "392171",
                    "sweep_txid": "d85f18f3755d85b2fb29f9331886c5e20c42749df7926c5202f6e21f41951047"
                },
                {
                    "resolution_type": "OUTGOING_HTLC",
                    "outcome": "FIRST_STAGE",
                    "outpoint": {
                        "txid_bytes": "6d746c50e31538401ce865b01b06d140aa54bc55a3417ad6951325dd48656056",
                        "txid_str": "56606548dd251395d67a41a355bc54aa40d1061bb065e81c403815e3506c746d",
                        "output_index": 1
                    },
                    "amount_sat": "399487",
                    "sweep_txid": "82ada5a715b24ac00dbc9ff7270a5aa701e899b7d83aea1846aafdb0283d3c52"
                },
                {
                    "resolution_type": "COMMIT",
                    "outcome": "CLAIMED",
                    "outpoint": {
                        "txid_bytes": "6d746c50e31538401ce865b01b06d140aa54bc55a3417ad6951325dd48656056",
                        "txid_str": "56606548dd251395d67a41a355bc54aa40d1061bb065e81c403815e3506c746d",
                        "output_index": 2
                    },
                    "amount_sat": "4638822",
                    "sweep_txid": "3a43bc132fb9fecaed0365d2a5e2b6ae4b9aa10bc21069cc8e40452bdc3c2fee"
                }
            ]
        },

seems to be a bug from lnd?

could there be any issue to abandon channel for a closed channel (beyond losing the history on this channel)?

[alexbosworth]

It seems weird that it says it's in FIRST STAGE forever yeah, I could see it if it were a very small amount