search

alexfun / rserve-surf-public

Example code for Alex's presentation to SURF Sep 2015 http://www.meetup.com/R-Users-Sydney/events/224485958/
GNU General Public License v3.0
1 stars 0 forks source link

Alternatives after 2 years? #1

Closed dselivanov closed 7 years ago

dselivanov commented 7 years ago

Thank you very much for sharing. Rserve and FastRWeb are really awesome applications, but documentation is sparse (and not that many people share their experience). I'm researching about how to convert my R application into high-performance web microservice with REST API. Rserve look like very solid solution (but still not sure how to combine it with some http server. now looking intoFastRWeb). Do you know any better alternatives? (mb something changed after 2 years). Thanks.

alexfun commented 7 years ago

Thanks for getting in touch. I have not really used R server side since I wrote this, however I am not aware of any other developments which let you replicate what FastRWeb has done, except possibly using some integration with Microsoft's Azure.

Back when I was using it, I did not find that it had any shortcomings. I wish I had time to explore supporting https, which I believe is supported but I did not test. But I am not a web developer so I do not know what other features one might want from an API service. In addition, it was able to multithread processes very well on my server, but it would be interesting to know whether you can add something like Amazon's elastic beanstalk on it to support variable loads.

If I may ask, how did you find this page?

dselivanov commented 7 years ago

I googled something about Rserve + FastRWeb and found meetup page with link to this repo. I'm not web developer as well. Couple of years ago I tried RServe with Java client (so all http related logic was on java side). And I was really impressed by low latency, scalability with number of cores and stability of Rserve. Quite similar approach is used by Domino Data Lab.

There are some less performant solutions like plumber or opencpu. And here is CRAN WebTechnologies task view which I found up to date and quite useful.

dselivanov commented 7 years ago

Once more thanks for sharing. Closing this issue.

alexfun commented 6 years ago

If you have some time, I would be keen to hear your thoughts on this article which mentions plumber and compares in to Rserve:

http://jaehyeon-kim.github.io/2017/11/API-Development-with-R-Part-I.html

dselivanov commented 6 years ago

@alexfun FYI I've developed https://github.com/dselivanov/RestRserve.

alexfun commented 6 years ago

Ah, looks interesting thanks. I have a chance to meet Jaehyeon (from above link). If I do I will let him know of your development.