alexkay / spek

Acoustic spectrum analyser
http://spek.cc
GNU General Public License v3.0
2.57k stars 257 forks source link

aiff - The file contains no audio streams - ODD tags only #137

Open todehefa opened 7 years ago

todehefa commented 7 years ago

Hi guys!

I have a problem, maybe you can help me. I can see the streams only if the AIFF file has a EVEN number of written tags. If I write/delete one more it won't work. (odd tags)

Have a nice day!

withmorten commented 6 years ago

Can you post a sample?

I just tested with kid3 tag editor a bit, and files tagged with that are broken with spek 0.8.2.

This is probably only insofar a problem of Spek as its current build uses incredibly outdated ffmpeg libraries - using a newer version I compiled against ffmpeg 3.2.4 the files that previously didn't open opened just fine.

Which OS are you on?

todehefa commented 6 years ago

I'm using Windows 10. So, in order to see the spectrum of an .aiff file that originaly show nothing in Spek (along with the message "The file contains no audio streams"), I will simply open it with Mp3tag and add/delete ONE tag information from that file. If i add/delete one more after that, it will not work again.

withmorten commented 6 years ago

You're in luck then, I made a "custom" version of Spek with all the new improvments + newer ffmpeg (which fixes an incredible amount of issues I had with Spek):

https://github.com/withmorten/spek/releases

Can you test if you have the same issues with this version?

todehefa commented 6 years ago

It really works!!! Thank you for your help :D !!

withmorten commented 6 years ago

Nice! I hope the official Spek gets updated at some point so more people can benefit from the better ffmpeg libraries and all the other little improvements ...

Hourri commented 6 years ago

@todehefa i got the same problem as you ! @withmorten thanks a LOT for this fix 😄

withmorten commented 6 years ago

Glad to hear that!

davconvent commented 6 years ago

Would it be possible to have a version that is OS X 10.11 compatible ? This one requires OS X 10.12. That would help a lot (I have same issue). Thx!

withmorten commented 6 years ago

Just compiled it on 10.11:

spek-0.8.2.3.zip

Since that seems to run on 10.12 with no problems I'll be switching out the dmg on the actual release page, too.

davconvent commented 6 years ago

Yes, it works smooth on 10.11 now, TYVM :-)