search

alsa-project / alsa-utils

The Advanced Linux Sound Architecture (ALSA) - utilities
GNU General Public License v2.0
200 stars 138 forks source link

amixer: needs sget/cget support in stdin mode #135

Open nick87720z opened 2 years ago

nick87720z commented 2 years ago

I used alsactl and amixer to implement highly effective volume control applet executor. At least it's able to keep pace at touchpad, which sends 1000 scroll events in only 18 to 12 seconds.

amixer --stdin handles control events, while alsactl monitor is even source for applet display part (it's tint2 executor). But in order to get values to display - this display part has to run alsactl sget per request. Can't these commands be supported in stdin mode? From first look - expected lines number doesn't look unpredictable: for sget it depends on number of channels, and for cget - probably fixed.

Even controls command also could be supported, since it lists channel from biggest ID to 1, so moment of numid=1 could be understood as end of list.

perexg commented 2 years ago

alsactl monitor = amixer events

It would probably make sense to send an end-of-output line in stdin mode (like ---END---) - using a new amixer argument. The numid=1 as the last line is not guaranteed for amixer controls.

nick87720z commented 2 years ago

alsactl monitor = amixer events

This looks more convenient than using alsactl. Using alsactl monitor, single amixer controls run is still necessary just to get proper channel ID to manage, while this gives all necessary info from start. Though at least in alsa-utils 1.2.4 it's indocumented (though imho, program help should usually be updated first). Although I just use gentoo's stable version (last version, keyworded as experimental, is 1.2.6).

perexg commented 2 years ago

Though at least in alsa-utils 1.2.4 it's indocumented (though imho, program help should usually be updated first).

Fixed in 68473a41c6fa68f3d8331ef995b25c2c84a0ef92 .

nick87720z commented 1 year ago

It would probably make sense to send an end-of-output line in stdin mode (like ---END---) - using a new amixer argument. The numid=1 as the last line is not guaranteed for amixer controls.

This starts to look like conventional shell with prompt string. I remember most cases they had it like % or > (not system shells, but rather command line utilities). There could be option command line option for user-supplied prompt.