amark / gun

An open source cybersecurity protocol for syncing decentralized graph data.
https://gun.eco/docs
Other
17.96k stars 1.16k forks source link

Remove offline gun volunteer relays #1305

Closed atjn closed 1 year ago

atjn commented 1 year ago

I have been testing my app on the volunteer servers for the past week. Most of them have been permanently down the whole week, and since they seem to be Heroku servers, I'd guess they are never coming back.

The list of working volunteers:

The list of offline volunteers

I want to remove these from the volunteer list, but since I have not really been involved in managing this list before, I wanted to ask for your feedback first. Is it okay to remove these servers?

Maybe an exception should be made for https://gun-ams1.cl0vr.co/gun, since it is not obviously a Heroku deployment?

Tagging most recent list editors: @wayjake @cl0vrfi3ld @draeder

cl0vrfi3ld commented 1 year ago

Hey there! I run the gun-ams1 relay. I haven't checked up on it recently, but I reckon it just ran out of credits. I'll look into it soon.

As for the rest, I think having some sort of GH action/bot to periodically clean up these entries would be pretty nice. It should post an issue of some sorts warning folks about the deletions, though, just in case anyone needs to double check their deployments.

atjn commented 1 year ago

@cl0vrfi3ld haha I wasn't smart enough to connect the URL with your name. Thanks for volunteering! A github bot would be really cool, but I don't know if it is wasted time to build one, given that AXE should automate this whole process very soon?

Anyways, while we wait for Github bot / Axe, would it be okay to remove the other URLS?

atjn commented 1 year ago

It seems @atom06 took this into their own hands. Then I guess there is no reason to debate it. Be aware that your relay is no longer on the list @cl0vrfi3ld .

wayjake commented 1 year ago

Thanks for the communication. Looks good!

It seems @atom06 took this into their own hands. Then I guess there is no reason to debate it.

READY FIRE AIM! :D

theatom06 commented 1 year ago

community service

wayjake commented 1 year ago

that's better than nothing 😂

theatom06 commented 1 year ago

maybe will look into make a bot @atjn

atjn commented 1 year ago

@atom06 if you want to build that, it would be very cool. Just know that AXE is being developed right now, and theoretically, it eliminates the need for a volunteers list.

theatom06 commented 1 year ago

when, and until then we need something "something is better than nothing"

Plus another side project wont hurt