map GeneralFormat and SpecificFormat

[VladimirAlexiev]

GeneralFormat and SpecificFormat are very useful classifications, please emit them. There are 11 GeneralFormat and 135 SpecificFormat. Since these are not mapped to AAT, make them out as a local 2-level thesaurus.

Take eg http://data.americanartcollaborative.org/page/aaa/object/1639 that should have type "Artworks" and subtype "cartoon (humorous image)". @workergnome @azaroth42 do you agree with this mapping:

<aaa/object/nnn>
  crm:P2_has_type
    <aaa/thesaurus/object/artworks>,
    <aaa/thesaurus/object/cartoon_humorous_image>.

<aaa/thesaurus/object/artworks> a skos:Concept;
  skos:inScheme <aaa/thesaurus/object/>;
  skos:prefLabel "Artworks".

<aaa/thesaurus/object/cartoon_humorous_image> a skos:Concept;
  skos:inScheme <aaa/thesaurus/object/>;
  skos:broader <aaa/thesaurus/object/artworks>;
  skos:prefLabel "cartoon (humorous image)".

[tobiashreiter]

@VladimirAlexiev , these have been mapped to AAT terms. We have extra spreadsheets in the data-v3 folder, one for general formats, and for specific formats, that links our local term to the AAT code and term.

[VladimirAlexiev]

• where are the sheets mapping GeneralFormat and SpecificFormat? I just pulled and I can't see them in
• occupations are mapped to AAT in "AAA Role Term mapping-final.xlsx", I'll note this in https://github.com/american-art/aac_mappings/issues/65
• Item_DigitalResources.xls is not usable because the ids-internal.si.edu server is not visible on the internet, right?

[tobiashreiter]

• They're in data-v3: AAA General Format Mapping To AAT.xlsx and AAA Specific Format Mapping To AAT.xlsx.
• That's correct. Just as a note, the mapping there are split into three tabs. The first tab maps to AAT, the second tab maps to Library of Congress Subject Headings (LCSH)
• The Item_DigitalResources file was updated on May 15th to use our publicly facing URL. If you have an older version of the file, it might have the old URL.

[VladimirAlexiev]

Weirdness: I see them in https://github.com/american-art/aaa/tree/master/data-v3. But when I Pull or Fetch (or even Revert), I don't see them in my working directory.

Same for Item_DigitalResources.xls:

• on the web I see Commits on May 16, 2017: Changes for Nikhila … Toby Reiter committed 2 days ago
• but locally I only see 5/5/2017 9:41:37 PM, Toby Reiter, Latest data export Made a task to map them: https://github.com/american-art/aaa/issues/13

[VladimirAlexiev]

Of course, it's better to emit AAT concepts. I propose this changed mapping:

<aaa/object/nnn> crm:P2_has_type aat:300133025, aat:300123430.

aat:300133025 a skos:Concept;
  skos:prefLabel "Artworks".

aat:300123430 a skos:Concept;
  skos:broader aat:300133025;
  skos:prefLabel "cartoon (humorous image)".

It would still be best to emit skos:broader according to AAA's 2-level classification. I've extracted it from objects (Item.xls) like this:

>csvcut -t -e cp1251 -c GeneralFormat,SpecificFormat Item.txt|sort|uniq -c>Item-Format.txt

Item-Format.txt @tobiashreiter can you add such column "parent" to AAA Specific Format Mapping To AAT.xlsx

[tobiashreiter]

@VladimirAlexiev , just to be very clear, are you simply asking that the general format be added to the specific format spreadsheet in the first column? If so, would you prefer our internal (AAA) vocabulary for general format, or the AAT term?

[tobiashreiter]

@VladimirAlexiev : I've added the general format (using our internal vocabulary) to the Specific Format Mapping sheet.

[VladimirAlexiev]

AAT is preferred for the extra col, but ISI can do that mapping

[tobiashreiter]

Great. And, as a reminder, that mapping is available in the General Formats spreadsheet.

[tobiashreiter]

Mapped, with local terms replaced with AAT terms (where available). Using AAT "document genre" for General Format, and "format" for Specific Format.