search

american-art / autry

Autry Museum of the American West
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
3 stars 2 forks source link

AutryMakers_new:Dates #32

Closed steads closed 8 years ago

steads commented 8 years ago

Dates: The construct of E39 ->P129i -> E33 ->P3 ->E62 is overly complex and confusing. The correct path should be:- E39(E21/E40) ->P3 ->E62 ->P3.1 -> E55 Type {Maker Dates Statement} In fact there is a lot more information hidden in this field. The birth dates of instances of E21 Person could easily be mapped as:- E21 ->P98i ->E67 ->P4 ->E52 ->P82 ->E61 ->P78 ->E50 The date of death of instances of E21 Person could easily be mapped as:- E21 ->P100i ->E69 ->P4 ->E52 ->P82 ->E61 ->P78 ->E50 The dates marked as active could be used together with the FRBRoo class of F51 Pursuit. In particular this would cope well with the entry for the instance of E40 Legal Body {Tiffany and Company}.

mayaram00 commented 8 years ago

Could you provide some clarification for what E39(E321/E40) means?

steads commented 8 years ago

E39 or its sub-classes E21 and E40

mayaram00 commented 8 years ago

so just to clarify, I created columns for both birth and death dates. Is it okay to do the suggested mappings directly from E39 Actor since E21 is a sub class?

steads commented 8 years ago

No it is not. E39 is not a valid range for the properties P98 and P100. Only E21 is as instances of E40 do not have births and deaths

mayaram00 commented 8 years ago

Changed