american-art / cbm

Crystal Bridges Museum
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
0 stars 2 forks source link

IMPORTANT missing titles for title type (not entered) #70

Closed VladimirAlexiev closed 7 years ago

VladimirAlexiev commented 7 years ago

CBM has some titles with type=0 "(not entered)"

grep ",0," *Title*/*.csv|head -10
# file:ObjectID,TitleID,Title,TitleTypeID,TitleType,DisplayOrder,DataDate
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1190,"1,222",Untitled,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1220,"1,252",Cooper Square,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1491,"1,574",Humble Birth,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1492,"1,575",Cube,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1494,"1,577",Untitled,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1499,"1,583",The Family,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1500,"1,584",Out Chorus,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1502,"1,586",People in Other Rooms (Harlem Street Scene),0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1503,"1,587",Revolt on the Amistad,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015
CBMAA_Titles/LOD CBMAA Titles.csv:1504,"1,588",Harriet,0,(not entered),1,12/23/2015

I checked the first 3 objects (eg http://data.americanartcollaborative.org/page/cbm/object/1492) and they don't have any title. Please map all titles: that is a crucial piece of info.

@workergnome we saw in the demo yesterday plenty of objects with no title, perhaps this is part of the reason why.

bsnikhila commented 7 years ago

I added them. Can you please check and let me know if it's alright?

VladimirAlexiev commented 7 years ago

@bsnikhila Checked a few, the title is there, but:

  1. It's better to use TitleID in the URL, not the title words. Else you may get conflicts with titles of other objects that have a type.
  2. According to the model, you also need to emit the title string as rdfs:label on the object

Cheers!

bsnikhila commented 7 years ago

Changed the URIs to use Title IDs.