search

ampproject / amphtml

The AMP web component framework.
https://amp.dev
Apache License 2.0
14.9k stars 3.88k forks source link

AMP Story Challenges for Video #39942

Open Prebid-Vertoz opened 3 months ago

Prebid-Vertoz commented 3 months ago

Description

Hello AMP Team,

I hope this email finds you well!

We are currently working on AMP storytelling for Video/VAST. However, we have encountered some challenges during the implementation of AMP story for video. These challenges include:

  1. When our video ad is positioned at the 5th position, users sometimes encounter the ad while visiting the 4th position. As a result, when users reach the 5th position, the ad is already completed. Could you please provide a solution so that the ad is rendered only when users visit the ad section?

  2. Due to issues such as fill rate, capping by demand, and others, we sometimes experience empty ad displays. Is there a way to remove the ad feed in such cases?

For reference, we have shared a test page below: https://textfeed.howgeneric.com/StoryVideoTest.html

Thank you in Advance

Reproduction Steps

Hello AMP Team,

I hope this email finds you well!

We are currently working on AMP storytelling for Video/VAST. However, we have encountered some challenges during the implementation of AMP story for video. These challenges include:

  1. When our video ad is positioned at the 5th position, users sometimes encounter the ad while visiting the 4th position. As a result, when users reach the 5th position, the ad is already completed. Could you please provide a solution so that the ad is rendered only when users visit the ad section?

  2. Due to issues such as fill rate, capping by demand, and others, we sometimes experience empty ad displays. Is there a way to remove the ad feed in such cases?

For reference, we have shared a test page below: https://textfeed.howgeneric.com/StoryVideoTest.html

Thank you in Advance

Relevant Logs

No response

Browser(s) Affected

No response

OS(s) Affected

No response

Device(s) Affected

No response

AMP Version Affected

No response

erwinmombay commented 3 months ago

@ychsieh could you take a look at this when you are back. thanks

Prebid-Vertoz commented 3 months ago

Hello Team, Any Update?

ychsieh commented 3 months ago

Please articulate how to reproduce the ad bug you mentioned. I didn't see any ads at the link you shared.

Prebid-Vertoz commented 1 month ago

Please articulate how to reproduce the ad bug you mentioned. I didn't see any ads at the link you shared.

As per shared Demo page url for Video story telling,we have two doubts : 1.When our video ad is positioned at the 5th position of Feed, users sometimes encounter the ad while visiting the 4th position. As a result, when users reach the 5th position, the ad is already completed. Could you please provide a solution so that the ad is rendered only when users visit the ad section?

2.Sometimes experience empty ad displays,Is there a way to remove the ad feed in such cases?

DEMO Page: https://textfeed.howgeneric.com/StoryVideoTest.html

Prebid-Vertoz commented 2 weeks ago

Hello @ychsieh I Hope you are doing well! Can you please share your insights on the above doubts?