amrisi / amr-guidelines

244 stars 87 forks source link

Proposal: Eliminate standard NE type public-institution #100

Closed uhermjakob closed 10 years ago

uhermjakob commented 10 years ago

Based on an analysis of NE types in our AMR release corpus, I propose to eliminate our standard NE type public-institution. It has not been used much in the first place, and when it has been used, it has been used very inconsistently. Some of the NEs marked as public-institution were courts (e.g. Old Bailey), but those are more appropriately annotated as government-organization since the courts are part of the judicial branch of government.

The one sole annotation with public-institution that seemed somewhat appropriate was for a prison, but then again, other prisons were annotated differently.

So I propose to fully eliminate the standard NE type public-institution. Most entities previously annotated as public-institution should be government-organization and prisons would be annotated as a facility (as we can't fully rely on them being run by the government any more, at least in the US).

In fact, I already took the liberty to do just that for the AMRs in the release under way.

nschneid commented 10 years ago

Sounds good to me.

uhermjakob commented 10 years ago

Final disposition: NE type eliminated (at the AMR phone meeting on Febr. 4, 2014).