Closed amrisi closed 10 years ago
Sounds good to me.
The expression "death penalty" is treated inconsistently. Most commonly in cjconsensus and ldcpreferred, it is (p / penalize-01 :instrument (d / die-01))
. Should this be converted to (p / penalize-01 :manner (d / die-01))
per your clarification?
Yes, these would be converted to (p / penalize-01 :manner (d / die-01))
as would generally all AMRs of the form (... :instrument (x / ...-01))
etc.
Clarification of :manner vs. :instrument adopted at AMR phone meeting on Febr. 11, 2014, as proposed.
Updated documentation at
At all annotation sites, please review all release-relevant instances of :instrument and correct as necessary. Thanks!
The current AMR corpus is not fully consistent with respect to usage of :manner vs. :instrument. We probably need to clarify the difference in the guidelines.
As a reference, here's what FrameNet uses. (They tend to split into more detailed roles.)
It has been my understanding that for AMR, we use
OK?