search

amrisi / amr-guidelines

250 stars 87 forks source link

Inconsistent use of have-org-role-91's :ARG3 #91

Closed uhermjakob closed 11 years ago

uhermjakob commented 11 years ago

I noticed some inconsistencies regarding have-org-role-91's :ARG3. In several instances, job titles such as "defense minister" or "chief of staff" were split up between :ARG2 and :ARG3, which I don't think was our original intention.

I added a section to the documentation page for have-org-role-91: http://www.isi.edu/~ulf/amr/lib/popup/have-org-role.html#arg2-arg3

The :ARG2 of have-org-role-91 is the office held, basically a job title in the wider sense. -- "What is he?" Example: "He is the school janitor."

 (h / have-org-role-91
       :ARG0 (h2 / he)
       :ARG1 (s / school)
       :ARG2 (j / janitor))

The :ARG3 of have-org-role-91 generally provides a description of the activity that the person performs, typically using verb frames -- "What does he do?"

Example: "He cleans bathrooms and empties the trash for the school."

 (h / have-org-role-91
       :ARG0 (h2 / he)
       :ARG1 (s / school)
       :ARG3 (a / and
             :op1 (c / clean-01
                   :ARG0 h2
                   :ARG1 (b / bathroom))
             :op2 (e / empty-01
                   :ARG0 h2
                   :ARG2 (t / trash))))

More under http://www.isi.edu/~ulf/amr/lib/popup/have-org-role.html#arg2-arg3

mgeorgescu commented 11 years ago

Hi Ulf,

We had several instances of this type but these were corrected for the release. Thank you for the clarification and for documenting this further. madalina