search

an-tao / trantor

a non-blocking I/O tcp network lib based on c++14/17
Other
401 stars 133 forks source link

Add botan2 support back for ubuntu, rockylinux #262. #349

Open hks2002 opened 3 months ago

hks2002 commented 3 months ago

@marty1885 Please consider add botan2 support back. There are too many OS pkg still using botan2. https://pkgs.org/search/?q=botan

marty1885 commented 3 months ago

I noticed the lack of Botan3 support in distros too. Thanks for bring up. However my dev rigs all runs Arch which only has Botan 3. It'll be quite difficult to make sure Botan 2 is working properly when there's no one actively using it.

I can add the support if there's active users of a Botan 2 backend and they are ok with reporting related bugs.

hks2002 commented 3 months ago

In my windows, botan3 is working, I add a way to prepare the dependencies build by source with Cmake FetchContent in my code, I tried to build botan3 in source for ubuntu, but the building is faild due to 8G mem is not enough for GCC compile. This also cause we can't build botan in github actions.

please add code:

#ifdef USE_BOTAN2
#ifdef USE_BOTAN3

in BotanTLSProvider.cc to handle different botan version.

marty1885 commented 3 months ago

It's not that easy. Botan2 and 3 have different interfaces and error handling. So much so and in security critical sections that I much prefer to separate the backends for Botan 2/3.