(Reaserch) Introduction of the logging mechanism

[andrii-itdev]

Google Cloud - Structured logging Google Cloud - Write log entries Serilog - Configuration

Serilog - NuGet extension for hosting Serilog - NuGet aspnetcore Serilog - NuGet Configuration

Sample Project

Who are the primary users of logs?

Developers:

• Debugging and Troubleshooting: Developers use logs to diagnose and fix bugs. Logs provide context on errors and the state of the application at various points in time.

• Performance/Memory Tuning: By analyzing logs, developers can identify performance issues and optimize the code.

System Administrators/DevOps Engineers:

• Monitoring and Maintenance: These professionals use logs to monitor the health and performance of systems. They set up alerts based on log patterns to detect issues proactively.

• Incident Response: Logs are crucial during incidents to quickly identify and resolve problems.

Security Teams:

• Intrusion Detection and Forensics: Security professionals analyze logs to detect unauthorized access, unusual activities, and to perform forensic analysis after security breaches.
• Compliance Audits: Security teams use logs to ensure that the system complies with regulatory standards and to provide evidence during audits.

Business Analysts:

• User Behavior Analysis: Analysts examine logs to understand how users interact with the software, which features are most used, and to identify usage patterns.
• Decision Making: Log data can provide insights that inform business decisions, product improvements, and strategic planning.

Customer Support

• Support teams use logs to help diagnose customer-reported issues, allowing them to provide more accurate and efficient assistance.

[andrii-itdev]

Logging serves several critical purposes:

Debugging and Troubleshooting: Logs provide a detailed record of what the software is doing at any given time. When a bug or an error occurs, logs can help developers trace the sequence of events leading up to the issue, making it easier to identify and fix the problem.

Security: Logs can be crucial for security purposes, such as detecting unauthorized access attempts, monitoring for suspicious activity, and investigating security breaches. Security logs can provide evidence and help in understanding the extent of an incident.

Analysis and Optimization: By analyzing logs, developers and analysts can gain insights into how users interact with the software, identify areas for improvement, and optimize performance. Logs can reveal patterns and trends that inform future development and enhancements.

[andrii-itdev]

Tools and Libraries

In C# .NET, there are several tools and libraries commonly used for logging:

Microsoft.Extensions.Logging

Description: A built-in logging framework provided by Microsoft as part of the .NET Core and .NET 5+ ecosystem.

        var loggerFactory = LoggerFactory.Create(builder => 
        {
            builder.AddConsole();
        });
        var logger = loggerFactory.CreateLogger<Program>();

        logger.LogInformation("This is an information message.");

NLog

Description: A popular third-party logging library known for its flexibility and ease of use. Features:

• Supports multiple targets (e.g., file, database, email, console).
• Provides advanced configuration options through XML or JSON.
• Supports structured logging and complex logging rules.

using NLog;

public class Program
{
    private static readonly Logger Logger = LogManager.GetCurrentClassLogger();

    public static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        Logger.Info("This is an information message.");
    }
}

<nlog>
  <targets>
    <target name="logfile" xsi:type="File" fileName="file.txt" />
  </targets>
  <rules>
    <logger name="*" minlevel="Info" writeTo="logfile" />
  </rules>
</nlog>

Serilog

Description: A highly configurable logging library designed with a focus on structured logging. Features:

• Supports a wide range of sinks (e.g., file, console, Elasticsearch, Seq).
• Provides rich data capture and structured logging.
• Easily integrates with .NET's built-in logging.

using Serilog;

public class Program
{
    public static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        Log.Logger = new LoggerConfiguration()
            .WriteTo.Console()
            .CreateLogger();

        Log.Information("This is an information message.");
    }
}

Log4Net

Description: A port of the popular Apache log4j framework for .NET, offering extensive logging capabilities. Features:

• Flexible and powerful logging framework.
• Supports hierarchical logging and multiple appenders.
• Configurable via XML or programmatically.

using log4net;

public class Program
{
    private static readonly ILog Logger = LogManager.GetLogger(typeof(Program));

    public static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        Logger.Info("This is an information message.");
    }
}

[andrii-itdev]

What Events should be logged?

Errors and Exceptions

• Error Messages: Any error messages generated by the application.
• Stack Traces: Details of exceptions, including stack traces, to facilitate debugging.
• Error Codes: If applicable, specific error codes associated with errors.

System Events

• Startup and Shutdown: Logs indicating when the application starts and stops.
• Configuration Changes: Any changes to the application configuration or environment.
• Service Health Checks: Results of health checks for services and dependencies.

User Activities

• Logins and Logouts: Successful and failed login attempts, including user IDs and timestamps.
• User Actions: Important actions performed by users, such as data creation, modification, deletion, and access.
• Access Control Changes: Changes to user roles, permissions, and other security-related configurations.

Transactions

• Transaction Start and End: When a transaction starts and ends, along with its status (success or failure).
• Transaction Details: Key details of transactions, such as transaction IDs, amounts, and involved entities.

Security Events

• Authentication Attempts: Both successful and failed authentication attempts.
• Authorization Checks: Logs of authorization checks, especially failures.
• Suspicious Activities: Potential security breaches, such as multiple failed login attempts or access from unusual locations.

Audit Trails

• Data Access: Who accessed what data, when, and what actions were performed.
• Administrative Actions: Actions taken by administrators, such as configuration changes and user management.

System Errors and Warnings

• Application Errors: Non-critical errors that do not cause the application to fail but are significant enough to be logged.
• Warnings: Conditions that might not be errors but could lead to issues if not addressed.

External Integrations

• API Calls: Outgoing and incoming API calls, including endpoints, payloads, and responses.
• Service Interactions: Logs of interactions with external services and databases.

What Information should be logged?

Performance Metrics

• Response Times: Time taken to process requests or perform operations.
• Resource Utilization: CPU, memory, and other resource usage metrics.
• Throughput: Number of requests handled per unit of time.

Debugging Information

• Debug Messages: Detailed information useful for debugging, such as variable values, function entries and exits, and state changes.
• Trace Information: Step-by-step execution details for complex operations.

Configuration Information

• Environment Details: Information about the environment in which the application is running, such as OS, version, and configurations.
• Configuration Parameters: Values of key configuration parameters at startup and during runtime changes.

[andrii-itdev]

Main Purposes of Sentry

• Error Tracking and Reporting: Sentry captures and reports errors and exceptions in your application, providing detailed information about the error, the context in which it occurred, and the stack trace.

• Performance Monitoring: Sentry monitors application performance by tracking metrics such as response times, throughput, and the performance of specific transactions. This helps identify performance bottlenecks and areas for optimization.

• Real-time Alerts: Sentry sends real-time alerts when errors occur or performance issues are detected, allowing developers to respond quickly to issues.

• Contextual Information: Sentry provides rich contextual information for each error, including the environment, the release version, user information, and custom metadata. This context helps developers understand the conditions under which the error occurred.

• **Aggregating Similar Issues: Sentry groups similar errors together, making it easier to identify recurring issues and track the overall impact of specific problems.

[andrii-itdev]

Logging libraries in the .NET ecosystem

In the .NET space, there are 3 big players:

• NLog
• log4net
• Serilog

NLog

• Configuration

Supports configuration via XML, JSON, and fluent API. Highly flexible with a range of options for configuring targets, rules, and layouts.

• Logging Targets/Sinks

File, Console, Database, EventLog, Email, Network, and more.

• Structured Logging

Limited support for structured logging compared to Serilog.

• Performance

High performance with asynchronous logging capabilities.

log4net

• Configuration

Primarily configured via XML. Supports programmatic configuration as well. Offers a wide range of appenders and layout options, but configuration can be cumbersome.

• Logging Targets/Sinks

File, Console, Database, EventLog, Email, Network, and more.

• Structured Logging

Basic support for structured logging, primarily through message templates.

• Performance

Good performance, but can be slower than NLog and Serilog due to its older architecture.

Serilog

• Configuration

Supports configuration via JSON, XML, and code-based configuration (fluent API). Highly flexible with a focus on structured logging. Easy integration with various sinks and enrichers.

• Logging Targets/Sinks

File, Console, Elasticsearch, Seq, Datadog, Application Insights, and many more.

• Structured Logging

  Designed with structured logging in mind. First-class support for logging structured data.

• Performance

Excellent performance, particularly in high-throughput scenarios.

Summary

NLog: Best for those looking for a flexible and high-performance logging library with a straightforward configuration. log4net: A mature option with extensive configuration options and a large user base, though it may require more effort to set up. Serilog: Ideal for modern applications that require structured logging and seamless integration with a variety of sinks. Offers excellent performance and ease of use.

[andrii-itdev]

Pros & Cons

Structure Logging Advantages

• Search and Filtering — Since each log event is structured, it becomes much easier to search through logs based on specific properties. You can filter logs based on any property within the structured data.
• Contextual Information — Structured logs provide context-rich information about the logged event. You can include objects, exceptions, and other data relevant to the event.
• Readability — Logs in a structured format are easier to read, especially for developers and tools. Log entries are self-describing, making it clear what each piece of information represents.
• Integration with Tools — Structured logs integrate well with various logging backends and log analysis tools. This includes ELK Stack (Elasticsearch, Logstash, Kibana), Seq, Splunk, etc.
• Consistency — Using structured logging encourages a consistent log format across an application or system. Team members can easily understand and work with logs from different parts of the application.
• Flexibility — You can easily add, remove, or modify properties in the structured logs. This flexibility allows developers to adapt logs to changing requirements without altering logging code extensively.
• Performance — Depending on the logging library and configuration, structured logging can be performant. Libraries like Serilog are designed to efficiently handle structured data serialization.

Structure Logging Disadvantages

• Complexity — Implementing structured logging might require a bit more setup and configuration compared to plain text logging.
• Learning Curve — Developers not familiar with structured logging formats might need some time to get used to working with them.

[andrii-itdev]

What are the features of Structured Logging?

Key-Value Pairs

Structured logging captures log data as key-value pairs, allowing logs to be more easily parsed, queried, and analyzed

Rich Data Context

With structured logging, you can include rich context in your log entries. Instead of just logging a message string, you can log additional structured data, such as user IDs, transaction IDs, and other relevant information.

Improved Queryability (Filtering and Search)

Because structured logs are stored in a structured format (e.g., JSON), they can be easily queried and analyzed using log management and analysis tools. This enables more effective troubleshooting and monitoring. You can filter logs based on specific fields and values, making it easier to pinpoint issues or analyze specific events.

Integration with Monitoring Tools

Structured logs integrate well with modern monitoring and observability tools, such as ELK (Elasticsearch, Logstash, Kibana) stack, Splunk, and Azure Monitor. These tools can ingest, index, and visualize structured log data efficiently.

Facilitates Automation and Alerting

Structured logging enables more effective automation and alerting. You can set up alerts based on specific log patterns or values, helping you proactively identify and respond to issues.

Compatibility with Machine Learning and Analytics

[andrii-itdev]

Possible Issue "(Research) Integration of ELK, Splunk, or Azure Monitor"