search

andstatus / andstatus

Multiple accounts client for multiple Social networks. For Android
http://andstatus.org/
Apache License 2.0
309 stars 71 forks source link

Content warning not intuitive #507

Closed BalooUriza closed 5 years ago

BalooUriza commented 5 years ago

When using networks that support content warnings/folds (e.g. Mastodon), there's presently no way to keep sensitive images or warned content from being displayed automatically. Likewise, creating a new Mastodon post with a CW is not intuitive.

yvolk commented 5 years ago

Yes, really. There is no special support of Mastodon's "CW" feature. Just more generic "Note Name/Title" notion is adapted to be used with Mastodon. Mastodon doesn't support "Name/Title", and I figured out that having mapping of more generic "Name" (which is used in Pump.io and ActivityPub) to Mastodon's "CW" is better than nothing...

BalooUriza commented 5 years ago

I agree, it's better than nothing on submitting (perhaps labeling the fields as such when posting to Mastodon and any other networks that support CWs would help). But on the reading side, not having CWs collapsed by default (or at least a way to enable collapsing them) is problematic due to NSFW posts.

yvolk commented 5 years ago

Do you think that this could help: "Collapse notes with titles" option in AndStatus Settings and "show" button in collapsed notes ("toots"...) (Initially without identifying, if the Title is a CW or a simply Name/Title) ?!

BalooUriza commented 5 years ago

Mostly, yes. If it's something that can be set as a default, even better. Obviously show the title even if it's CW stuff, but collapse the rest. Something similar should happen with media on posts with sensitive media that isn't CW. By comparison, Tusky get sensitive media and content warning right but can't hang on phones with lots of data dropouts.

yvolk commented 5 years ago

This is anoher case, as I understand:

Something similar should happen with media on posts with sensitive media that isn't CW...

I didn't understand fully, starting with this phrase. How do I know if the media is sensitive if the note doesn't have any title/name/CW text?

BalooUriza commented 5 years ago

I believe it's a subset of the same case, I don't fully understand the internal workings of Mastodon, but it is possible to send a toot that has the images hidden and the text not.

On Thu, May 2, 2019, 09:40 Yuri Volkov notifications@github.com wrote:

This is anther case, as I understand:

Something similar should happen with media on posts with sensitive media that isn't CW...

I didn't understand fully, starting with this phrase. How do I know if the media is sensitive if the note doesn't have any title/name/CW text?

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/andstatus/andstatus/issues/507#issuecomment-488700212, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAWDFBS6HNQEJXZWCAD7CPTPTL4OHANCNFSM4HJRTPJA .

yvolk commented 5 years ago

The second case with media only is not the the same, if we don't extract Mastodon - specific "sensitive" flag from the Note...

yvolk commented 5 years ago

OK, so I see that instead of a hack we really need to add separate "Sensitive" property that could be used both in Mastodon and at least in ActivityPub.

See this thread regarding ActivityPub: https://github.com/w3c/activitypub/issues/231 In ends with the proposed extension: "sensitive" property" (see https://www.w3.org/wiki/Activity_Streams_extensions#as:sensitive_property )

And I see that Twitter has similar property also: "possibly_sensitive"

yvolk commented 5 years ago

Released in v.50.01