search

ankitects / anki-manual

Anki's manual
https://docs.ankiweb.net
495 stars 173 forks source link

Discrepency between Anki Options and Anki manual: Minimum Interval #294

Open joshdavham opened 2 weeks ago

joshdavham commented 2 weeks ago

There's currently a descrepency between how the Anki Options pane describes the Minimum Interval parameter and how the Anki manual describes it:

Anki Options pane (version 24.06.3):

min_int_options

Anki manual:

min_int_manual

I'm still learning how the default Anki scheduler works so I'm actually not sure which one is correct.

If anyone knows which is the correct one, I'd be happy to open a PR to correct it.

brishtibheja commented 2 weeks ago

Both are correct explanations. The tooltip says it's the minimum interval after selecting Again on a review card i.e. after the card has lapsed and gone through relearning.

joshdavham commented 2 weeks ago

How I interpret the tooltip is that, if I have a review-state card and I hit again, it will be due no earlier than the minimum interval.

The manual on the other hand gives the interpretation that, once a relearning-state card has been rated good(and maybe also easy?) on its last relearning step, it will be due no later than the minimum interval.

These two interpretations are both plausible and incompatible.

brishtibheja commented 2 weeks ago

it will be due no later than the minimum interval.

It's the default behaviour as by default new interval = 0.00. If you read that topic later, maybe it becomes clear (well, I have really ignored those sm-2 parts of docs).

joshdavham commented 2 weeks ago

I've read the manual, the tooltips and the faqs.

Deck_Options_-_Anki_Manual

brishtibheja commented 2 weeks ago

The manual is correct. The default new interval resets the delay to 0. But with the default minimum interval it jumps back to 1 day.

joshdavham commented 2 weeks ago

The manual is correct.

Ok.

But is the manual also correct in the section describing the Minimum Interval? As I've demonstrated, the descriptions of the Minimum Interval between the manual and the Anki tooltip are discrepant.

brishtibheja commented 2 weeks ago

But is the manual also correct in the section describing the Minimum Interval?

It is but it's slightly confusing because it implied setting minimum interval to 1d makes your interval after relearning 1 day even though that may increase with new interval. You can fix that by making the end part, "meaning once relearning is finished the card has at least a 1d interval" or something better.

(though, imo we're better off spending time rewriting other parts of the docs)

joshdavham commented 2 weeks ago

once relearning is finished the card has at least a 1d interval

Is this correct?

If so, the minimum interval does a lot more than what is communicated in the tooltip or the manual alone.

brishtibheja commented 2 weeks ago

If so, the minimum interval does a lot more than what is communicated in the tooltip or the manual alone.

I'm not sure. I think that's what the manual/tooltip is communicating. If you have something in mind, you can do a PR.

joshdavham commented 2 weeks ago

If you have something in mind, you can do a PR.

I'm not going to open a PR until I understand what the minimum interval actually does. It's why I opened this issue.