search

ansible-collections / community.rabbitmq

Manage RabbitMQ with Ansible
http://galaxy.ansible.com/community/rabbitmq
Other
30 stars 46 forks source link

Unmaintained collection: Removal from Ansible (community) package #164

Closed mariolenz closed 5 months ago

mariolenz commented 6 months ago

It looks like this collection is effectively unmaintained. According to the current community guidelines for collections, we will consider removing it in a future version of the Ansible community package. Please see Unmaintained collection: community.rabbitmq for more information.

At least one month after this announcement appears here and on Bullhorn, the Ansible Community Steering Committee will vote on whether this collection is considered unmaintained and will be removed, or whether it will be kept. If it will be removed, this will happen earliest in Ansible 11. Please note that people can still manually install the collection with ansible-galaxy collection install community.rabbitmq even when it has been removed from Ansible.

felixfontein commented 6 months ago

Since this is a community collection, and some users (both maintainers and drive-by contributors) are still quite interested in this, I think it would be great if instead of being removed it could get a bit more active!

@g0tmi1k @csmart you recently (in the last half a year) merged PRs, so it seems there are still folks around with commit rights. Do you need more help? Do you still have time/interest to work on this?

mariolenz commented 6 months ago

@felixfontein Yes, this is a little bit weird... people seem to be working on this collection but there are no releases. I don't understand this :shrug:

At the end of the day, just fixing / improving things in the repo but not releasing is a problem IMHO...

csmart commented 6 months ago

I can find some more time to work on this and pick up on the releases... IMO let's not remove it yet and see how we go.

mariolenz commented 6 months ago

IMO let's not remove it yet and see how we go.

@csmart Just to make this clear, it's not a question of removing the collection yet / now. Even if we would decide to remove it, it would be comparatively easy to cancel the removal as long as Ansible 11 hasn't been released yet. And I guess this will be somewhere in November.

BTW if you do find the time to work on a new release, maybe you should consider making it a major one (2.0.0) and drop support for some older / EOL versions of ansible-core as I've suggested in #162. It's not a requirement, but it might make you life easier. If nothing else, it would speed up the CI pipeline and save resources.

csmart commented 5 months ago

FYI, version 1.3.0 has been release which includes bug fixes and new feature to manage users via the API.

mariolenz commented 5 months ago

Thank you very much @csmart!