search

ansible / galaxy-issues

This repository exists solely for the tracking of user issues with Ansible Galaxy.
20 stars 3 forks source link

Roles import with GitHub owner name rather than Galaxy owner name #246

Closed natefoo closed 7 years ago

natefoo commented 7 years ago

We have a project account for our roles at https://galaxy.ansible.com/galaxyprojectdotorg/ which is linked to the @galaxybot GitHub account. As I'm a member of the galaxyproject GitHub org and have granted access to that org for my individual Galaxy account, I can also see and trigger imports for galaxyprojectdotorg roles under my individual account.

We have created a new role, galaxyproject/ansible-proftpd. This role now appears under my individual Galaxy account. However, when importing under my individual account, Galaxy created the role as galaxyproject.proftpd rather than galaxyprojectdotorg.proftpd. So I logged in under the galaxyprojectdotorg Galaxy account using the @galaxybot GitHub account and navigated to "My Roles." The full list of galaxyprojectdotorg roles was displayed there, not including the new proftpd role. Upon clicking "Refresh your Repositories from GitHub", all of the roles disappeared except galaxyprojectdotorg.galaxy.

I have verified that @galaxybot has the needed permissions on the galaxyproject org. What's gone wrong here?

natefoo commented 7 years ago

The roles appear now, it was a permissions problem with @galaxybot's teams. However, the role still imports as galaxyproject.proftpd. It looks like Galaxy is importing roles using the GitHub repo owner name rather than the Galaxy owner name.

natefoo commented 7 years ago

FWIW I am perfectly happy renaming our roles to galaxyproject, but (back when he was still at Ansible) Michael DeHaan had asked us to change from galaxy to galaxyprojectdotorg due to the unfortunate project name collision.

chouseknecht commented 7 years ago

That's the expected behavior. We changed it, maybe 2 years ago now to import under the GitHub namespace.

natefoo commented 7 years ago

Ok, thanks. I guess I'll reimport our old roles, then? Or can their names be fixed somehow?

chouseknecht commented 7 years ago

I think the right thing to do is to move them to the GitHub namespace. Otherwise, each time your team creates a role, it will be an issue.

chouseknecht commented 7 years ago

Closing.

chouseknecht commented 6 years ago

This issue was moved to ansible/galaxy#71