ansuz / RIIR

why not Rewrite It In Rust
https://transitiontech.ca/random/RIIR
638 stars 6 forks source link

Determine reason for RIIR requests #5

Open pmcoder opened 8 years ago

pmcoder commented 8 years ago

I think its lack of adoption. Other languages that take off do so because developers find it useful and some of the things you want to see rewritten because either the devs want to port or other devs want a project written in their language of choice with the hopes of forming a community. What I've seen of Rust though makes me think most find it too cumbersome and the zealots that want to push it (probably a vocal minority) don't have the chops to rewrite the projects they target on their own even if its a toy implementation. I think they fall in love with the language but the lack of love from others annoys them to the point of trying to force it.

KellerFuchs commented 7 years ago

@pmcoder Well, there is a large Rust community out there, and most of the time the zealots feel like they aren't actually part of it. In any case, it's strange and figuring out why it is happening would be interesting.

One thing I would point out, though, it that this sort of proselytism is fairly commonplace in the free software communities: Ask an Emacs question? Get told that clearly you should use NeoVim. Mention that you are learning Go? Clearly Javascript would be better, since it runs everywhere... (Note that those are random examples off the top of my head, and not meant to disparage specific projects) Commonplace, however, doesn't mean it should be acceptable: this kind of behaviour makes it very hard for newcomers to actually get help and learn what they are trying to learn, while teaching them that aggressive proselytism is the norm.

ansuz commented 7 years ago

Aggressive proselytism is definitely the norm.

Also, vim is better than emacs.

QED

tchaffee commented 7 years ago

This looks like it is still open and no one has offered to work on it? Can I take this issue?

ansuz commented 7 years ago

@tchaffee, please do

tchaffee commented 7 years ago

There might be some danger involved concerning internet points. When I tried to point out to a Rust post on Hacker News that a new feature written in Rust might be better implemented in Rust, there was little humor to be had.

selection_067

dmerejkowsky commented 6 years ago

@KellerFuchs

there is a large Rust community out there, and most of the time the zealots feel like they aren't actually part of it.

I believe you're right. Well said.