apache / cordova-docs

Apache Cordova Documentation
https://cordova.apache.org/
Apache License 2.0
351 stars 559 forks source link

Documentation splashscreen #1274

Open NiklasMerz opened 1 year ago

NiklasMerz commented 1 year ago

Feature Request

Motivation

We should make the documentation for the splashscreen easier to find and understand. Some people approached me and asked for help because getting the splashscreens right can be hard.

Status quo

Room for improvement

I will talk to some people and try to make a few small changes that improve this. Feel free to help here:

Any further ideas?

Simone4e commented 1 year ago

Can someone add an example of that res/screen/android/splashscreen.xml file?

Because at the moment I have the structure mentioned in the documentation but we don't know how to create a good xml.

breautek commented 1 year ago

Can someone add an example of that res/screen/android/splashscreen.xml file?

Because at the moment I have the structure mentioned in the documentation but we don't know how to create a good xml.

The cordova hello world app uses https://github.com/apache/cordova-android/blob/master/templates/project/res/drawable/ic_cdv_splashscreen.xml

However, it looks like it's not really following the recommended sizing. Cordova uses the Icon with background setting, so the android docs states:

App icon with an icon background: this must be 240×240 dp and fit within a circle 160 dp in diameter.

Looks like our vector is a 512x512dp instead of 240x240. It still does the job appearently but I'd probably recommend trying to follow the Android suggested sizing here.

To parse out what android expects, it expects 240x240dp canvas with your "icon" graphic fitting inside 160dp circle in the center. Everything outside of that circle is an unsafe area that might be masked away. It may be clipped when drawn, or during any android animations.

Note that android expects an Android Vector Drawable (AVD) which is different from an SVG. I believe a SVG may work but android doesn't implement a full SVG feature set and using something that android doesn't have implement will result in a crash. Android Studio does have a tool to convert SVGs and and PSD files into AVDs.

dp refers to display independent pixel. It's a size relative to Android's base density, which is mdpi. You can use these values as is if you're authoring a vector as vectors can be scaled appropriately on-the-fly. Alternatively you can author a PNG, but you'll have to scale them up to the max resolution you intend to support. For example, xxxhdpi is ~4x the density of the base mdpi, so you'll need to multiply all dp units by 4. Therefore a correct PNG canvas is 960x960 px with 640 px diameter circle.

Personally I use rasterized PNGs in my projects with no problems but they are less efficient and not recommended by Android. Namely because importing PSDs using that aforementioned tool doesn't appear to work for me :/

Simone4e commented 1 year ago

Can someone add an example of that res/screen/android/splashscreen.xml file? Because at the moment I have the structure mentioned in the documentation but we don't know how to create a good xml.

The cordova hello world app uses https://github.com/apache/cordova-android/blob/master/templates/project/res/drawable/ic_cdv_splashscreen.xml

However, it looks like it's not really following the recommended sizing. Cordova uses the Icon with background setting, so the android docs states:

App icon with an icon background: this must be 240×240 dp and fit within a circle 160 dp in diameter.

Looks like our vector is a 512x512dp instead of 240x240. It still does the job appearently but I'd probably recommend trying to follow the Android suggested sizing here.

To parse out what android expects, it expects 240x240dp canvas with your "icon" graphic fitting inside 160dp circle in the center. Everything outside of that circle is an unsafe area that might be masked away. It may be clipped when drawn, or during any android animations.

Note that android expects an Android Vector Drawable (AVD) which is different from an SVG. I believe a SVG may work but android doesn't implement a full SVG feature set and using something that android doesn't have implement will result in a crash. Android Studio does have a tool to convert SVGs and and PSD files into AVDs.

dp refers to display independent pixel. It's a size relative to Android's base density, which is mdpi. You can use these values as is if you're authoring a vector as vectors can be scaled appropriately on-the-fly. Alternatively you can author a PNG, but you'll have to scale them up to the max resolution you intend to support. For example, xxxhdpi is ~4x the density of the base mdpi, so you'll need to multiply all dp units by 4. Therefore a correct PNG canvas is 960x960 px with 640 px diameter circle.

Personally I use rasterized PNGs in my projects with no problems but they are less efficient and not recommended by Android. Namely because importing PSDs using that aforementioned tool doesn't appear to work for me :/

In my old version project my xml was:

      <splash density="land-hdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-hdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="land-mdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-mdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="land-xhdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-xhdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="land-xxhdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-xxhdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="land-xxxhdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-xxxhdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="port-hdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-hdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="port-mdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-mdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="port-xhdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-xhdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="port-xxhdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-xxhdpi/screen.png" />
      <splash density="port-xxxhdpi" src="res/screen/android/drawable-xxxhdpi/screen.png" />

That code resizes the image, is there no way to use similar code for the new version using variants in PNG?

breautek commented 1 year ago

That code resizes the image, is there no way to use similar code for the new version using variants in PNG?

Two things I think worth mentioning on this:

1) The android's splashscreen system is vastly different than what Cordova had implemented via the splashscreen plugin. What you get to control is the background colour of the splashscreen and a small area, about the same size as an app icon, that's about it. So those existing launch screens that you had before will not work on Android's splashscreen system.

2) I'm not sure on the rationale on this, but Cordova writes the splashscreen icon asset to the drawable-nodpi directory, which effectively tells Android that that asset is to be used for all densities. I'm not sure if this is a requirement of Android's splashscreen API.

Generally speaking, the ....../src/res/ directory has several sub directories like mipmap-<density> where you can place different resolution images by density and the android system will pick up the appropriate one to use. But I'm not sure if Android obeys this for the splashscreen given that Cordova doesn't seem to do this. Cordova via splashscreen settings doesn't expose this, but once you have a working splashscreen image, you could try using

<resource-file src="mySrc/res/android/xxxhdpi-splashicon.png" target="res/mipmap-xxxhdpi/ic_cdv_splashscreen.png" />

But honestly, I don't really see the point in doing that unless if you actually have problems rendering xxxhdpi assets on lower end devices. And if that's the case, might be better just to get an AVD instead.

Simone4e commented 1 year ago

That code resizes the image, is there no way to use similar code for the new version using variants in PNG?

Two things I think worth mentioning on this:

  1. The android's splashscreen system is vastly different than what Cordova had implemented via the splashscreen plugin. What you get to control is the background colour of the splashscreen and a small area, about the same size as an app icon, that's about it. So those existing launch screens that you had before will not work on Android's splashscreen system.
  2. I'm not sure on the rationale on this, but Cordova writes the splashscreen icon asset to the drawable-nodpi directory, which effectively tells Android that that asset is to be used for all densities. I'm not sure if this is a requirement of Android's splashscreen API.

Generally speaking, the ....../src/res/ directory has several sub directories like mipmap-<density> where you can place different resolution images by density and the android system will pick up the appropriate one to use. But I'm not sure if Android obeys this for the splashscreen given that Cordova doesn't seem to do this. Cordova via splashscreen settings doesn't expose this, but once you have a working splashscreen image, you could try using

<resource-file src="mySrc/res/android/xxxhdpi-splashicon.png" target="res/mipmap-xxxhdpi/ic_cdv_splashscreen.png" />

But honestly, I don't really see the point in doing that unless if you actually have problems rendering xxxhdpi assets on lower end devices. And if that's the case, might be better just to get an AVD instead.

I think currently using a simple PNG directly with <preference name="AndroidWindowSplashScreenAnimatedIcon" value="res/screen/android/drawable-xxhdpi/screen.png" />, you mentioned earlier changing the diameter of the circle it contains the image, is there the relative xml code string?

breautek commented 1 year ago

you mentioned earlier changing the diameter of the circle it contains the image, is there the relative xml code string?

I'm not really sure if I'm really understanding the question here. If you're asking what XML places the icon in that circle, it's the AndroidWindowSplashScreenAnimatedIcon preference itself. The supplied image is the 240dpx240dp canvas, that should have it's content fitting inside a 160dp diameter circle.

If you're asking if I have an XML vector that draws a circle then No... I don't have sample XML that does that on hand, but that circle is imaginary, unless if you want to draw an actual circle. It's just that your icon content should fit inside that space and not use the edges/corners of the canvas.

See this example graphic...

Screenshot from 2023-06-28 09-33-41

This is an example provided by Android. Their GMail logo fits within the 160dp diameter circle and does not exceed the space outside of it. The "circle" is not visible, it's just used to describe how to author your graphic.