Open jayzhan211 opened 1 week ago
Hello @jayzhan211 , I am trying to ramp up the repo via porting the min_max tests to sqllogictests.
During the migrations, however, I found there are inconsistent behavours. An example is error handling inside rust class versus through the SQL engine as such:
Before:
let left = ScalarValue::Decimal128(Some(123), 10, 2);
let right = ScalarValue::Decimal128(Some(124), 10, 2);
let result = max(&left, &right)?;
assert_eq!(result, right);
let right = ScalarValue::Decimal128(Some(124), 10, 3);
let result = max(&left, &right);
let err_msg = format!(
"MIN/MAX is not expected to receive scalars of incompatible types {:?}",
(Decimal128(Some(123), 10, 2), Decimal128(Some(124), 10, 3))
);
let expect = DataFusionError::Internal(err_msg);
assert!(expect
.strip_backtrace()
.starts_with(&result.unwrap_err().strip_backtrace()));
After:
statement ok
DROP TABLE decimals;
statement ok CREATE TABLE decimals_error (value DECIMAL(10, 2));
statement ok INSERT INTO decimals_error VALUES (123.00), (arrow_cast(124.00, 'Decimal128(10, 3)'));
124
As far as I could tell, the error will be lost permanently.
What's your opinions on such migrations? Shall we keep the tests that are different still in the rs files?
I think we don't need to keep the test. The reason that you didn't get the error is that we have coercion already in building values. It is the expected result.
Is your feature request related to a problem or challenge?
There are many rust test that exists in aggregate functions. Moving them to sqllogictest is easier to maintain and avoid additional testing functions like
generic_test_op
,assert_string_aggregate
,assert_aggregate
,assert_error_bounds
, and so on. It also makes #8708 a lot easier.10382 is an example of how tests are moved to.
I think most of them are Good first issue:
Describe the solution you'd like
Port rust test in
datafusion/physical-expr/src/aggregate/tdigest.rs
todatafusion/sqllogictest/test_files/aggregate.slt
We can just add the test to
aggregate.slt
even if there is a duplicated test case to make the review easier.Describe alternatives you've considered
No response
Additional context
No response