search

apache / nuttx

Apache NuttX is a mature, real-time embedded operating system (RTOS)
https://nuttx.apache.org/
Apache License 2.0
2.92k stars 1.19k forks source link

stm32_otgfsdev not working on stm32f411-minimum #8968

Open ALTracer opened 1 year ago

ALTracer commented 1 year ago

Summary

I can't get USB OTG to work in device mode on WeAct BlackPill STM32F411CEU6 rev 3.1 in CDC/ACM, MSC and COMPOSITE configurations.

Impact

Possibly all stm32f4-based boards and dwc2 IP users without VBUS_SENSE pad routed.

Description

As I was bringing up some more configs for stm32f411-minimum, I stumbled upon non-working USBDEV. USBHOST won't work because I didn't bridge VBUS with onboard 5V pin yet, and I don't need USBHOST on this board.

I see several issues in stm32_otgfsdev driver code:

  1. VBUSASEN/VBUSBSEN bits are written unconditionally. Does NOVBUSSENS actually override them in this IP core version? 
    
diff --git a/arch/arm/src/stm32/stm32_otgfsdev.c b/arch/arm/src/stm32/stm32_otgfsdev.c
index a0a9ecb70..7bf89426c 100644
--- a/arch/arm/src/stm32/stm32_otgfsdev.c
+++ b/arch/arm/src/stm32/stm32_otgfsdev.c
@@ -5362,9 +5362,11 @@ static void stm32_hwinitialize(struct stm32_usbdev_s *priv)
* Sense when Set
*/
  1. CONFIG_STM32_USBDEV_REGDEBUG option is unreachable. I added it to Kconfig myself to achieve the following trace:
diff --git a/arch/arm/src/stm32/Kconfig b/arch/arm/src/stm32/Kconfig
index 214a31ef3..7094ea2a6 100644
--- a/arch/arm/src/stm32/Kconfig
+++ b/arch/arm/src/stm32/Kconfig
@@ -11088,6 +11088,15 @@ config STM32_USBFS_REGDEBUG

 endmenu

+menu "USB OTG Device Debug Configuration"
+
+config STM32_USBDEV_REGDEBUG
+       bool "Register-Level Debug for OTG in Device mode"
+       default n
+       depends on USBDEV && DEBUG_USB_INFO
+
+endmenu
+
 menu "OTG Configuration"
        depends on STM32_OTGFS

I input sercon, msconn, conn and disconn. The latter triggered an assert because my Gentoo Host cannot enumerate this device.

ern  :info  : [ +18.810180] usb 1-8: new full-speed USB device number 20 using xhci_hcd
kern  :err   : [  +0.204052] usb 1-8: device descriptor read/64, error -71
kern  :err   : [  +0.280011] usb 1-8: device descriptor read/64, error -71
kern  :info  : [  +0.281943] usb 1-8: new full-speed USB device number 21 using xhci_hcd
kern  :err   : [  +0.205060] usb 1-8: device descriptor read/64, error -71
kern  :err   : [  +0.280995] usb 1-8: device descriptor read/64, error -71
kern  :info  : [  +0.106046] usb usb1-port8: attempt power cycle
kern  :info  : [Apr 5 11:16] usb 1-8: new full-speed USB device number 22 using xhci_hcd
kern  :warn  : [  +0.026800] usb 1-8: Device not responding to setup address.
kern  :warn  : [  +0.236003] usb 1-8: Device not responding to setup address.
kern  :err   : [  +0.205205] usb 1-8: device not accepting address 22, error -71
kern  :info  : [  +0.179008] usb 1-8: new full-speed USB device number 23 using xhci_hcd
kern  :warn  : [  +0.026811] usb 1-8: Device not responding to setup address.
kern  :warn  : [  +0.237983] usb 1-8: Device not responding to setup address.
kern  :err   : [  +0.204205] usb 1-8: device not accepting address 23, error -71
kern  :err   : [  +0.004012] usb usb1-port8: unable to enumerate USB device

Wireshark usbmon0 traces later. STM32 DfuSe USB BootROM works.

ALTracer commented 1 year ago
NuttX-12.0 / master serial log ``` NuttShell (NSH) NuttX-12.0.0 nsh> uname -a NuttX 12.0.0 ca9b3271d Apr 5 2023 11:05:58 arm stm32f411-minimum nsh> ps PID GROUP PRI POLICY TYPE NPX STATE EVENT SIGMASK STACK USED FILLED CPU COMMAND 0 0 0 FIFO Kthread N-- Ready 0000000000000000 001000 000564 56.4% 100.0% Idle Task 1 1 100 RR Task --- Running 0000000000000000 002000 001204 60.2% 0.0% nsh_main nsh> free total used free largest nused nfree nsh> help help usage: help [-v] [] . cat dmesg memdump mksmartfs rmdir truncate [ cd echo help mount set uname ? cp env hexdump mv sleep umount alias cmp exec irqinfo printf source unset unalias dirname exit kill ps test uptime basename dd false ls pwd time usleep break df free mkdir rm true xd Builtin Apps: conn disconn msconn msdis nsh sercon serdis sh nsh> srcon nsh: srcon: command not found nsh> sercon sercon: Registering CDC/ACM serial driver sercon: Successfully registered the CDC/ACM serial driver nsh> msconn mcsonn_mausbmsc_exportluns: Starting SCSI worker thread in:usbmsc_scsi_main: Started usbmsc_exportluns: Waiting for the SCSI worker thread Cusbmsc_exportluns: Signalling for the SCSI worker thread rusbmsc_scsi_main: Waiting to be signaled eusbmsc_scsi_main: Running ating block drivers mcsonn_main: Configuring with NLUNS=1 mcsonn_main: handle=0x2000db90 mcsonn_main: Bind LUN=0 to /dev/smart0 mcsonn_main: Connected nsh> ps PID GROUP PRI POLICY TYPE NPX STATE EVENT SIGMASK STACK USED FILLED CPU COMMAND 0 0 0 FIFO Kthread N-- Ready 0000000000000000 001000 000564 56.4% 99.3% Idle Task 1 1 100 RR Task --- Running 0000000000000000 002000 001204 60.2% 0.6% nsh_main 6 6 128 RR Kthread --- Waiting Semaphore 0000000000000000 002008 000444 22.1% 0.0% scsid nsh> conn coboard_mscclassobject: Configuring with NLUNS=1 nboard_mscclassobject: MSC handle=n0x2000d9e0 _board_mscclassobject: Bind LUN=0 to /dev/smart0 musbmsc_exportluns: Starting SCSI worker thread ain:usbmsc_scsi_main: Started usbmsc_exportluns: Waiting for the SCSI worker thread Pusbmsc_exportluns: Signalling for the SCSI worker thread eusbmsc_scsi_main: Waiting to be signaled rusbmsc_scsi_main: Running forminstm32_getreg: 50000804->00000002 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 gstm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04008c20 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04008c20 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000800 stm32_usbsuspend: resume: 0 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04008420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 architecture-specific initialization conn_main: Exiting nsh> stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808c20 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809c20 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001800 stm32_usbsuspend: resume: 0 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808c20 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808c20 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000800 stm32_usbsuspend: resume: 0 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808c20 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04809c20 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00001800 stm32_usbsuspend: resume: 0 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000014->0480a420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00002000 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_putreg: 50000900<-00008000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000100 stm32_getreg: 5000000c->40001840 stm32_putreg: 5000000c<-40001840 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808c20 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808c20 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000800 stm32_usbsuspend: resume: 0 stm32_getreg: 50000014->04808420 stm32_getreg: 50000018->000c3812 stm32_putreg: 50000014<-00000000 disconn stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000010<-00000020 stm32_getreg: 50000010->80000000 stm32_getreg: 50000804->00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000804<-00000000 stm32_putreg: 50000908<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b08<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000928<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b28<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000948<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b48<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000968<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000b68<-000000ff stm32_putreg: 50000818<-ffffffff stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000814<-0000000b stm32_putreg: 50000810<-0000000b stm32_getreg: 50000800->00200003 stm32_putreg: 50000800<-00200003 stm32_getreg: 50000900->00008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_getreg: 5000081c->00010001 stm32_putreg: 5000081c<-00010001 stm32_putreg: 50000b10<-60080018 stm32_getreg: 50000b00->80008000 stm32_putreg: 50000b00<-84008000 _assert: Current Version: NuttX 12.0.0 ca9b3271d Apr 5 2023 11:05:58 arm _assert: Assertion failed priv->thstate == (8) || priv->thstate == (0): at file: usbdev/usbmsc.c:417 task: disconn 0x80157ad up_dump_register: R0: 00000000 R1: 20001de4 R2: 40011000 R3: 00000000 up_dump_register: R4: 2000d4c0 R5: 00000000 R6: 0802390d FP: 2000f110 up_dump_register: R8: 20000bc0 SB: 080238e0 SL: 000001a1 R11: 00000000 up_dump_register: IP: 00000008 SP: 2000f0f0 LR: 08012bed PC: 08015648 up_dump_register: xPSR: 61000200 BASEPRI: 00000080 CONTROL: 00000000 up_dump_register: EXC_RETURN: fffffff9 dump_stack: IRQ Stack: dump_stack: sp: 0x2000f110 dump_stack: base: 0x200003c0 dump_stack: size: 00002048 dump_stack: ERROR: IRQ Stack pointer is not within the stack dump_stack: User Stack: dump_stack: sp: 0x2000f110 dump_stack: base: 0x2000ea98 dump_stack: size: 00002008 stack_dump: 0x2000f100: 2000d548 080157ad 00000200 08020613 00000000 7474754e 20000058 0801c0da stack_dump: 0x2000f120: 2000f1e8 080076e7 08020012 2000f1e0 0000001c 2000f1e8 00000000 080072f9 stack_dump: 0x2000f140: 2000f160 50000b00 2e323100 00302e30 20000bc8 50000b00 84008000 616300f0 stack_dump: 0x2000f160: 32336239 20643137 20727041 32203520 20333230 303a3131 38353a35 08020600 stack_dump: 0x2000f180: 2000f198 080145f9 2000f1ac 2000f198 6d7261bd 08020600 2000f1a4 00000000 stack_dump: 0x2000f1a0: 0801493d 0801c0da 2000d9e0 20000bd0 00000000 000000f0 2000d8e8 0000004c stack_dump: 0x2000f1c0: 00000000 08006e93 00000002 08019627 2000d888 20000bd0 00000000 000000f0 stack_dump: 0x2000f1e0: 2000d8e8 0801b353 0801b2c9 20000bd0 2000d9d0 000000f0 00000080 00000000 stack_dump: 0x2000f200: 00000000 08002a3f 20001e90 2000d888 20001e90 2000ea88 00000000 0801b4fb stack_dump: 0x2000f220: 2000f240 20001e90 2000ea88 08014111 00000203 00000000 20001e90 080157ed stack_dump: 0x2000f240: 00000203 20001e90 2000ea88 080157ad 00000001 080070e3 00000000 080045c3 nsh> ```
ALTracer commented 1 year ago

Also see discussion in #8906 and https://github.com/libopencm3/libopencm3-examples/issues/178. Summoning @raiden00pl for good measure because of involvement in RNDIS, COMPOSITE and stm32h7. Maybe even @davids5 (thanks for allowing disabling GPIO_OTG_ID!)

ALTracer commented 1 year ago

Wireshark:

with NuttX firmware, host gets -EPROTO and 0-length USB URB in response to GET DESCRIPTOR Request DEVICE to 1.0.0 0-address destination. Request-response time is 0.3ms-1.0ms. Then hosts sends RESET to USBHUB (this is AMD Ryzen 3200G B450M desktop and USB2.0 front panel port, no issues with Full Speed devices) and repeats DESCRIPTOR Request. 0-length responses. I'll need to look at physical level later, something's wrong. NuttX throws a lot of USBDEV_REGDEBUG traces I enabled, into 0x50000000-0x50001000 region. Without them (synchronous 1-byte FIFO USART at 115200 is /dev/console aka arm bit-bucket, so might slow down) nothing much changes.

with STM32 DfuSe BootROM, host gets URB status success and 18-length data, also a DFU Mode descriptor. Then assigns an address (39 today) and repeats descriptor request-response to this address, all the usual handshake stuff. First request-response time is 2.7ms.

davids5 commented 1 year ago

@ALTracer Have a look at the reference manual and see of the IP block uses on the stm32411 look line the one on the F466/F469

[See comment in #if defined(CONFIG_STM32_STM32F446) || defined(CONFIG_STM32_STM32F469) /* In the case of the STM32F446 or STM32F469 the meaning of the bit

ALTracer commented 1 year ago

@davids5 Maybe you didn't read my #8906 ?

Moving half of comment from PR to this issue:

I see something funny in otgfsdev driver code: https://github.com/apache/nuttx/blob/d3f659b85427401c334aea8f2c633516222f7982/arch/arm/src/stm32/stm32_otgfsdev.c#L5361-L5369 F446, F469 and MP15x have a newer DWC2 and only VBDEN bit in ther GCCFG register. F411 has a slightly older revision and is controllable by all the bits: VBUSASEN. VBUSBSEN, NOVBUSSENS.

STM32F411CE Reference Manual contains a OTG Device mode programming sequence, where they tell to write the VBUSBSEN bit to enable Vbus B-mode sensing logic, if VBus pad is muxed. Or they tell to write the NOVBUSSENS bit if VBus pad is not connected.

NuttX driver code writes BOTH VBUSASEN, VBUSBSEN unconditionally, and there is no git history for these two lines since basically 2015. Sure, some might say after NOVBUSSENS this is largely irrelevant, but 1) it contradicts the RM; (not really, it's just not stated) 2) there are multiple threads/GH-issues in libopencm3 which consider this subject/problem of non-working OTG device on F411 and friends.